Document Type: Original Article

Designing the Evolutionary Model of the Iran Electricity Market Ecosystem, a Co-Creation in the Electricity Industry Value Chain Approach

Volume 17, Spring&Summer2025, August 2025, Pages 61-91

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.91049.1641

Alireza Khodabandeh, Mohsen Moradi, Seyed Morteza Ghayor Baghbani, Davood Manzoor

Abstract 1- INTRODUCTION
The article discusses the dynamics of the Iran's electricity market ecosystem. It aims to design an evolutionary model for this ecosystem, focusing on identifying value chain actors, evolutionary drivers, and areas of value co-creation. Traditionally, the electricity supply chain included generation, transmission, and distribution, operating independently. Under restructuring, the power supply becomes a semi-liberal market activity. The article emphasizes the balance between integration and competition forces, crucial for ecosystem sustainability. Value co-creation, driven by collaboration among actors, aims to achieve innovation and improved economic, social, and environmental performance.

2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Digital transformation, driven by technological innovation, changing consumer behavior, and operational efficiency needs, has significantly altered the business landscape and impacted traditional models (Sasha et al., 2024). The research highlights the importance of adaptive strategies and digital competencies. Sjödin et al. (2024) emphasize the need for new capabilities—ecosystem foresight, integration, and governance—to manage complex business ecosystems. Diamond et al. (2023) calls for more research on ecosystem decline and propose strategies for ecosystem development. Flynn and Foss (2023) focus on value theory’s role in ecosystem growth and capability, criticizing current studies for lacking micro-foundations. Espina-Romero et al. (2022) review literature from 2018 to 2022, identifying key and less-studied topics in business ecosystem research. PESTLE tool (Henry, 2021) was used to analyze co-creation fields in the ecosystem; Economical and technological domains alongside combining legal and political factors into one domain and social and environmental factors into another, are highlighting collaboration and value co-creation.

3- METHODOLOGY
A model similar to SGAM is used to map and display the target model, which includes the three dimensions of actors, evolutionary drivers, and areas of value co-creation. Identification of evolutionary drivers of the ecosystem of Iran's electricity industry was done using thematic analysis of semi-structured interviews. To conduct and analyze the semi-structured interview, the method proposed by Adeoye‐Olatunde & Olenik (2021) including seven stages was used.
After the three dimensions of the model are obtained, the relationships between dimensions should be expressed mathematically. Here, the actors are the nodes of the cognitive map, whose degree of interaction and influence on each other in each of the fields of value co-creation is obtained as the edges by gathering the opinions of experts. In order to obtain the final cognitive map of the influence of players, four cognitive models of value co-creation areas, according to the weights given by the experts, are combined and an aggregate cognitive map is formed; This collective cognitive map assures all aspects of interactions lead to co-creation of value in different areas have been considered.
The drivers have their influence on the actors; This effect is applied through the nodes of the aggregated cognitive model graph. Therefore, the presented cognitive model is a model that, in addition to the edges that have values in traditional models, graph nodes also have values due to the influence of drivers on actors, so classical models of cognitive map solving cannot be used, and other methods of matrix analysis should be used. By reviewing the existing literature, the permanent matrix value approach was chosen to analyze the model. This new approach is based on graph theory and matrix algebra and has some desirable features (such as the ability to model interactions, the ability to structure problems hierarchically, etc.) for modeling and solving complex decision-making problems.

4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
semi-structured interview was used along with to identify the actors of the ecosystem of the Iranian electricity market. As mentioned before, in this standard model, the main actors of the electricity market form the ecosystem of the electricity market with other actors. By summarizing the interviews conducted, the green market, the optimization market, the wholesale market and the energy exchange as the main actors of the market domain and network regulation and management, transmission-major subscribers-distribution, production including scattered energy sources, legislator and service provider as the acting domains. The ecology of Iran's electricity market was obtained.
In this study, 181 thematic codes were mentioned by 16 participants, which were first categorized into 55 basic drivers and then 6 strategic drivers. These drivers included incentive policy with an emphasis on energy efficiency, privatization and reform of financial and liquidity processes, imbalance in electricity production and consumption, facilitation of macro interactions, development of electricity market mechanisms and finally sanctions and restrictions.
By aggregating the weights given by experts and applying them in the areas of value co-creation, the aggregated fuzzy cognitive map matrix was determined. Fuzzy logic with positive and negative values was used to measure the effect of each evolutionary drive on each actor. If this number is negative, it means having a contraction effect on the actor in the ecosystem, and if it is positive, it will indicate the expansion and dynamic effect of the actor in the ecosystem. With this, the main diameter of the final matrix of the cognitive map has a value. The sensitivity analysis of the above matrix is used to determine the overall contraction or expansion of each driver.

5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Drivers of the development of electricity market mechanisms, incentive policies with emphasis on energy efficiency, privatization and reform of financial circulation processes and facilitation in macro transactions and the drivers of sanctions and restrictions as well as disharmony, respectively They are centrifugal or expansive in the production and consumption of electricity. Therefore, the output of the fuzzy cognitive map model, which is obtained by analyzing the sensitivity of the sustainable value matrix of the ecosystem, is the selection of two basic drivers that have the greatest impact on the expansion and contraction of the ecosystem, namely, the development of Iran's electricity market mechanisms and the imbalance in electricity, which are Two are the strategic drivers of the ecosystem of Iran's electricity market. Resolving the imbalance in electricity requires the development of infrastructure, including grids, facilities, power plants, and gas production and transmission systems. In contrast, the development of electricity market mechanisms does not require a high investment and using successful experiences in the world, methods for improving these mechanisms are obtained.

Investigating the Effect of Networking Capability on Ambidextrous Innovation Mediated by Knowledge Applications

Volume 16, Spring&Summer2024, July 2024, Pages 66-99

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.86592.1539

Vahid Khashei Varnamkhasti, Rouzbeh Darvishi, Sajad Farsi

Abstract  
 
1- INTRODUCTION
Knowledge-based firms are the engine of economic growth and development of a country. These businesses are too important because they contribute to the countries' economic growth and development by creating jobs. These businesses operate in highly dynamic and competitive environments that face significant and often unpredictable technological, political, and economic changes. For this purpose, the development of ambidextrous innovation has become one of the basic requirements for these businesses to maintain their competitive position. Today, factors such as embargoes, government laws, traditional businesses, instability of economic conditions, and currency fluctuations prevail and increase the level of uncertainty in this environment. On the other hand, the provision of banking services has also been accompanied by many changes and differences such that they should meet the special needs of their customers. Today, knowledge-based firms in banking information technology are considered the banks' technological arms for providing new financial products and services. For this reason, improving ambidextrous innovation capability through absorbing knowledge and creating a network with stakeholders and key partners is very important. For this purpose, the current research seeks to answer the question, "How does networking capability affect ambidextrous innovation of banking information technology firms?"
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Networking capability is the ability of an organization to build, expand, and benefit from internal and external organizational relationships. Ambidextrous innovation can be defined as simultaneously implementing exploitative and explorative innovation activities. Therefore, ambidextrous innovation helps organizations to achieve optimal performance both in the short- and long-term. Networking capability allows the organization to actively seek external knowledge, compare it with its internal knowledge, and use it to identify opportunities. Organizations use networking capabilities to search across a wide range of strategic partners to discover or exploit ideas or practices that are not accessible through conventional routines. Knowledge application refers to a set of activities that explain how to connect external knowledge elements within or between organizational areas, analyze the connections between them, and prepare the absorbed knowledge for use in the relevant unit.
 
3- METHODOLOGY
In terms of purpose, this is a practical, cross-sectional quantitative research. In terms of method and data collection, it is a descriptive survey. The needed data was collected through a written questionnaire. The target population was comprised of 19 knowledge-based firms in the field of information technology and banking communication located in Tehran, all of which were sampled by distributing 5 questionnaires among their senior and middle managers. The sample members had more than 3 years of job tenure and relevant positions. Finally, 91 well-qualified questionnaires were returned. The gathered data was analyzed by conducting structural equation modeling to test the research hypotheses.
 
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
The results of the data analysis confirmed all the research hypotheses. Accordingly, networking capability had a direct and significant effect on ambidextrous innovation. Furthermore, networking capability directly affected the application of knowledge, which in turn had a significant effect on ambidextrous innovation. The results of the Sobel test revealed that the application of knowledge significantly mediated the relationship between networking capability and ambidextrous innovation.
 
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Based on the research findings, it is suggested that managers cooperate with other firms by creating strategic alliances. Developing such collaborations leads new knowledge to entering the organization and improves organizational explorative innovation. Strategic alliances may increase strategic flexibility by attracting new resources, reducing possible costs and risks, and improving the organization's efficiency. Consequently, it increases exploitative innovation in the organization. Networking capability allows firms to improve the provision of new banking services, provide consulting services, and increase customer satisfaction. This capability allows firms to create a consortium from scientific centers as well as strategic partners for research and development in line with identifying and exploiting market opportunities. Managers are also recommended to attract new knowledge to their firms by establishing partnerships with research centers as well as their strategic partners. Creating such networks leads to the exchange of information and experiences between the members, which ultimately improves the organization's explorative innovation. Through analyzing financial transactions as well as customer feedback data, managers should pay attention to the absorption of transformative knowledge to improve the firm's innovative performance.

Designing an organizational resilience model in the face of crisis and Organizational Rip Currents

Volume 16, Autumn&Winter2025, January 2025, Pages 71-106

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.87597.1563

Ali Shariatnejad, Reza Sepahvand, Hadi Rezaeinejad

Abstract  
1- INTRODUCTION
Organization-ripping forces are external factors beyond the control of organizations that, influenced by environmental factors and structural or behavioral weaknesses, lead to instability and reduced efficiency. These forces, often seen in developing countries with frequent government changes and the appointment of incompetent managers, can impact structures, technology, and personnel in organizations like a tsunami, causing severe damage and even dissolution. Crisis management and organizational resilience are two key approaches to countering these forces. Crisis management involves recognizing warning signals and taking preventive measures to either avert a crisis or minimize its impact. Organizational resilience, on the other hand, is defined as the organization’s ability to recover and adapt to unexpected changes. In facing disruptive forces, strengthening resilience and crisis management can help organizations survive shocks and even return to normalcy after a crisis. This article, by reviewing existing literature and presenting an integrated model, aims to offer solutions for enhancing organizational resilience in the face of crises and disruptive forces.
 
2- METHODOLOGY
This research utilizes qualitative and exploratory data. The method employed is thematic analysis, which aims to identify and analyze patterns of meaning within a dataset. The thematic analysis allows the researcher to focus on both explicit meanings and the underlying assumptions and theories hidden in the words and phrases used in the data. In this study, themes were extracted from codes and further developed through interpretive data analysis. Purposeful sampling was used, and relevant sources were gathered from reputable national and international databases. In the initial search, 279 sources were identified, and after screening based on title, abstract, and methodology, 53 sources were selected for final analysis. Given the lack of English sources on "organizational rift currents," the search period for this variable was set from 2016 to 2023. For "crisis management" and "organizational resilience," sources from 1998 to 2023 were reviewed. To ensure the reliability of the research, Cohen's Kappa coefficient was employed, with a re-coding of 20% of the codes by the researchers. The agreement rate for all components exceeded 70%. This study focuses on extracting and analyzing themes related to organizational rift currents, crisis management, and organizational resilience.
 
3- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
This research identified three overarching themes regarding organizational resilience and crisis management. The first theme, organization-ripping forces, encompasses constructive strategies such as enhancing an organization's capacity to adapt to critical changes, implementing necessary measures for responding to sudden disruptions and crises and fostering a culture of problem-solving during unexpected and critical situations. The second theme, crisis management, includes critical actions such as the necessity of rapid decision-making and acting in crises, coordinating efforts to mitigate sudden disruptive events, and evaluating potential threats arising from uncontrollable and rapid environmental changes. The third theme, organizational resilience, means addressing key strategies for monitoring and predicting changes to develop preparedness and response plans, analyzing external factors and sudden shocks, and enhancing resilience through adaptability. It also emphasizes the creation of a resilient human resource system, improving resilience in the face of unforeseen disruptions, utilizing data dashboards for information analysis during crises, and aligning management strategies to combat sudden disruptive events.
The research employed a thematic analysis approach six-phase framework. This process involves familiarizing with the data, generating initial codes, searching for themes, reviewing themes, defining themes, and writing the final report. A total of 279 documents were collected from various sources, including Emerald, Google Scholar, ResearchGate, ScienceDirect, and others, with the search focusing on organization-ripping forces, crisis management, and organizational resilience. The data were analyzed using Atlas.ti 9, and through multiple iterations, 1065 quotations were identified, from which 835 distinct codes were extracted. After refining and consolidating the codes, 702 final codes were identified, leading to 61 foundational themes and 14 organizing themes, which were then grouped into three comprehensive themes: organization-ripping forces, crisis management, and organizational resilience.
The first step in the analysis involved identifying initial codes from the data, followed by the grouping of these codes into abstract categories known as organizing themes. These organizing themes were then grouped into broader, overarching themes. For instance, codes related to marketing innovation were grouped under a single organizing theme. In the final phase of thematic analysis, 61 foundational themes were discovered, which were then categorized into 14 organizing themes, eventually leading to the identification of three main themes.
 
4- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
The research highlights that managers must focus on strengthening organizational resilience as a preventive approach when facing crises such as ripping currents. Additionally, evaluating how recovery priorities align with pre-crisis planning and communication efforts is crucial. Ignoring this issue can lead to the organization's collapse in a short period. Despite the extensive research on organizational resilience and crisis management, the study identified a gap in the literature regarding organizational resilience in response to ripping forces. This research aims to address this gap by providing a model for organizational resilience when facing crises and ripping forces. In conclusion, the data identified through thematic analysis resulted in a model comprising 14 organizing themes and 61 foundational themes across three main themes, providing a comprehensive understanding of organizational resilience, crisis management, and ripping forces.

Enterprise Risk Management and Corporate Social Responsibility: The Moderating Role of Real Earnings Management

Volume 15, Spring & summer 2023, September 2023, Pages 73-98

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2023.81222.1404

Gholamreza Farsidoost, Mehdi Moradi, Abolfazl Soleimani

Abstract 1- INTRODUCTION
Companies operate in an environment where the public expects them, in addition to their ability to generate profits, to maintain a balance between business growth and social progress. Therefore, corporate social responsibility has become an inevitable priority for business leaders. Furthermore, the activities of companies are different in terms of the degree of risk-taking, and thus, risk management is of great concern for them in dynamic global environments. Organizational risk management pays special attention to more effective identification of risks and social communication of the company. Also, to reduce the effects of uncertainty on the company's performance, managers can manage profit within a framework of accounting standards by affecting the structure of actual transactions and maintaining the stock price and support of their shareholders. But what the general investors understand about social responsibility is to report the companies' financial issues transparently.
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
As a ranking factor instead of internal control, risk management targets the companies' strategy to manage their attitude and exposure to risk and increase their value. Theoretically, a manager's trust or willingness to participate in social responsibility relates to corporate governance and the company's executive motivations. Social responsibility is morally optional rather than morally required, and the risk management model strengthens a manager's economic incentive to allocate some company resources to social responsibility activities. The agency perspective of social responsibility argues that entrenched managers in a company with strong corporate governance may use social responsibility activities to collude with shareholders to gain higher management authority to benefit from personal interests. In other situations, managers who are ascertained of positive benefits from these activities may choose social investments even if they are not value-adding. Factors such as capital market pressure, product market competition, and job-related incentives can motivate managers to perform earnings management. When the company has more effective organizational risk management, it has more potential opportunities, so managers may be less willing to manipulate profits. Managers use actual earnings management more when the risk management system is relatively weak. Some managers believe that social responsibility can reduce the possibility of disclosure of companies' participation in earnings management by providing the interests of the beneficiaries and presenting an image of social and environmental concerns. Earnings management practices harm the collective interests of stakeholders. Hence, the managers who manipulate the profit can address the activism and vigilance of the stakeholders through social responsibility methods.
 
3- METHODOLOGY
This research is a quantitative study. Its strategy is multiple linear regression and moderated regression analyses based on panel data. Needed data was gathered from 102 companies admitted to the Tehran Stock Exchange (TSE) from 2015 to 2021. Eviews software (version 12) was used to analyze the data.
 
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
The results show that the variable of organizational risk management has a positive and significant effect on the variable of corporate social responsibility. This result may be because risk management leads managers to social responsibility activities by creating a top-down view and guiding future harmful risks from society that may take the company off the track of success. Also, the interactive variable of actual earnings management with organizational risk management has a positive and significant effect on the variable of corporate social responsibility. The interaction of real earnings management strategy with risk management provides the necessary platform through increasing short-term productivity and consequently removing the managers' concern about maintaining their position and interests, encouraging them to carry out socially valuable activities with future benefits.
 
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Effective organizational risk management can reduce the effects of individual and general risks on the company's social responsibility goals. Companies with more effective risk management are more willing to invest in humanitarian activities. Also, actual earnings management can affect organizational risk management preferences that are applied to increase social responsibility activities. Our results have critical strategic implications for stakeholders and regulators regarding managerial opportunism and corporate governance mechanisms. Managers should focus more on organizational risk management and actual earnings management in the framework of accounting standards to maintain a sustainable competitive advantage.

Explaining the Role of Female Employees’ Psychological Safety in the Relationship between Knowledge Hiding and Job Performance and Helping Behaviors: Moderating Role of Organizational Cynicism

Volume 14, Autumn & Winter 2023, February 2023, Pages 84-120

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2023.74809.1263

Ghasem Eslami, Maryam Rahimnia, Marzieyh Adibzadeh

Abstract  
1- INTRODUCTION
In modern communities, the importance of women’s participation is to such an extent that achieving development is unexpected without their presence. Women play a remarkable role in the success of organizations due to a set of personality and innate characteristics, including a broad vision of the future, high administrative discipline, and their ability to motivate their colleagues and communicate with them as the life of an organization depends on the accurate performance of its personnel. Another critical factor in the success of organizations is the existence of employees who go beyond their job descriptions to help their colleagues. Though studies have shown that women are more likely than men to be involved in helping behaviors others argue that helping behaviors bring about challenges like the risk of emotional exhaustion or the reduced power of the helpful party to complete their official duties. Nonetheless, investigations have shown that employees who achieve success in their work may have more cognitive resources to participate in social behaviors and perform their occupational duties in a better way. Thus, job success can be considered an effective factor in helping behaviors and performance at work. However, some studies have shown that women experience lower levels of energy and enthusiasm at work. One of the most basic causes of that situation is the unfair interference of biological differences between men and women in occupational fields in addition to stereotypical attitudes and prejudices. an important consideration that should not be overlooked is that the feelings of security, justice, self-sufficiency, and autonomy matter a lot for women and increase their efficiency at work. Consequently, female employees’ mental security is a matter that requires urgent attention. On the other hand, knowledge is one of the main resources that each organization can utilize to achieve and maintain a competitive advantage, and the role played by women should not be overlooked in that regard. Though managers expect their employees to freely share their knowledge, it should not be forgotten that knowledge hiding is a common phenomenon, as well, and can significantly harm relationships in workplaces. Based on the above discussion, the present study contributed to the literature on organizational behavior and human resources in the field of women. First, it referred to the role of mental security as it could create a positive atmosphere and reduce the negative consequence of knowledge hiding, with a remarkable role in enhancing the efficiency of individuals and their colleagues at work. Another contribution of the present study concerned the role of female employees’ attitudes in professional relationships.
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Knowledge hiding refers to a conscious attempt by people to hide or prevent expressing knowledge that has been requested by someone else. Mental security indicates the feeling that people can present and utilize their abilities without any fear of losing their faces or positions or experiencing other negative consequences. The relationship between knowledge hiding and mental security can be illustrated using Bem’s Self-perception theory. The theory argues that people are involved in a process of self-attribution after carrying out a certain behavior and contemplating the action and the conditions leading to it. Scholars believe this can be attributed to the area of hidden knowledge in which the lack of mental security or similar conditions (for the individuals themselves or other people) extensively specifies the conditions under which hidden behaviors occur.
Success is defined as a psychological condition where people experience both feelings of liveliness and learning in their workplaces. Liveliness and joy can be considered the energy coming from job attachment, while learning is the result of acquiring new skills and knowledge. In other words, when employees are provided with working conditions having certain resources like communication and knowledge resources or social structure characteristics like information sharing and an atmosphere of respect, they are likely to experience job success.
The existence of mental security reduces employees’ likely concerns and allows them to concentrate on their duties. Moreover, it drives them toward active participation in communicative acts and the collection of feedback from others and boosts dynamic social interactions among employees. Thus, it can be claimed that mental security is a prerequisite for employees’ success at work.
Helping behaviors are defined as voluntary assistance offered to colleagues to fulfill one’s goals or prevent the emergence of problems, while job performance can be considered the intended values of an organization that people carry out within a specified period. Employees who experience job success are more likely to develop in their jobs, have more enthusiasm toward their positions, and, at the same time, improve their relationships with their colleagues. Thus, they are expected to show more helping behaviors. In this way, job success makes employees keep away from egocentrism and help others out of altruism. Job success is accompanied by feelings of liveliness and learning, which in turn result in improved performance. Thus, job success is a significant factor influencing the emergence of helping behaviors and the improvement of individual performance.
Organizational pessimism is a negative reflection of one’s attitudes and beliefs toward an organization. People who have pessimistic views toward their organizations are more likely to hide their knowledge due to risky or uncertain conditions so that they may preserve their sense of mental security.
 
3- METHODOLOGY
The present research was an applied study in terms of purpose, and in terms of method, it was a survey. The variables were investigated using the statistics standardized in the previous studies. Moreover, the validity of the constructs of the utilized questionnaires was evaluated using the confirmatory factor analysis in AMOS, and the significance of the items relevant to the intended constructs was confirmed. The level of analysis in the study was individual. The statistical population was comprised of all female employees in the public offices of Mashhad, Iran, out of whom 386 questionnaires were collected. The data were analyzed using various statistical procedures, including Pearson’s correlation coefficient to calculate the zero-order correlation coefficients and Structural Equation Modeling to investigate the fit of the structural equation model with the collected data.
 
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
As a prerequisite for the utilization of latent variables in structural equation modeling is the existence of a correlation between variables, Pearson’s correlation analysis was carried out. The obtained coefficients indicated that the pairwise relationship between all variables was significant at p<0.01. Moreover, the factor loadings of the items of the questionnaire were calculated using the confirmatory factor analysis in AMOS. As all factor loadings were significant in the fit model of confirmatory factor analysis, no item was eliminated from the analysis stage. Furthermore, all fit indicators were investigated, and it was shown that they enjoyed convenient fit. The hypotheses were investigated using p-value and t-value, and it was shown that, for all hypotheses in the study, the values obtained for the first and second indicators were below 0.05 and beyond the range of ±1.96, respectively. The moderating role of organizational pessimism was investigated using the adjusted regression analysis, and the hypothesized moderating impact was confirmed.
 
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
The present study aimed to investigate causal relationships between knowledge hiding, mental security, job success, and employees’ pessimism toward their organizations, and the data were collected from female employees in public offices in Mashhad, Iran. As predicted by the first hypothesis, it was shown that knowledge hiding negatively affects the mental security of female employees. In this way, it could be argued that hiding prevented organizational development due to its negative impacts on mental security. Concerning the second hypothesis, it was shown that knowledge hiding reduces job success. To reduce knowledge hiding, managers of human resources are suggested to establish contexts like work groups so that employees can both express their views and get familiar with what they should and should do at work. The third finding of the study showed that mental security had a significant impact on employees’ job success. Thus, it could be argued that as the positive resources created at the workplace increase, employees are more likely to actualize their capabilities toward effective behaviors. Concerning the fourth and fifth hypotheses, the effect of job success on job performance and organizational citizenship behavior was confirmed. Testing the mediating variables showed that mental security mediated the relationship between knowledge hiding and job success. Moreover, the mediating role of job success in the relationship between knowledge hiding and job performance and helping behaviors was confirmed. Ultimately, the moderating role of organizational pessimism was confirmed. The results showed that increasing organizational pessimism exacerbated the negative impacts of knowledge hiding on mental security. As employees’ pessimistic views indicate that justice and honesty are missing according to them (or may reduce in the future), managers need to ensure their employees that such basic principles will never be violated and take steps toward the expansion of justice and equity in their organizations.

Identifying the Antecedents and Consequences of Hooliganism in Mashhad Municipality

Volume 17, Autumn 2025 and Winter 2026, December 2025, Pages 85-117

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.92286.1684

Hamed Erfaniyan dabbaghnoghani,, Hamed KhorasaniToroghi, Vahid Mirzaei

Abstract This research aims to identify the antecedents and consequences of hooliganism in Mashhad Municipality. This study is based on qualitative methodology and content analysis method based on Brown and Clark method. The statistical population consisted of 21 academic and organizational experts active in Mashhad Municipality who were interviewed semi-structured until theoretical saturation. Sampling in this research was done by snowball method. That is, at the end of each interview session, the participant was asked to introduce a person who possessed knowledge and expertise in this field. The strategy for selecting organizational experts was also based on executive activities and management background, which required having at least 10 years of executive and management experience and having a master's or doctoral degree in one of the fields of management, educational sciences, and psychology. The analysis was conducted using MAXQDA software to ensure the reliability of the interviews. The structured process technique of convergent interviews and the technique of having at least two people conduct the interviews separately but in parallel were used. A total of 77 open codes of primary concepts, 20 sub-themes or basic themes, and 2 main themes were extracted from the research findings. Finally, threats for personal goals, insulting and disrespectful behavior, threats of demotion or dismissal, poor adherence to ethical principles, abuse of power for unethical purposes, lack of transparency and poor communication, poor organizational culture and leadership, poor internal monitoring and control, lack of effective or transparent policies, use of force and threats as precursors to bullying and Factors such as decreased work motivation, decreased work quality, decreased trust, increased job conflicts, creating an atmosphere of fear and insecurity, increased job abandonment, increased employee dissatisfaction, decreased productivity, decreased performance, and damage to the organization's reputation were identified as consequences of hooliganism.

Studying the Process of Changing the Employees’ Meaning Construction Due to the Manager's Discursive Activity

Volume 15, Autumn & Winter 2024, February 2024, Pages 90-113

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.80336.1390

Saeid Sehat, Mahdi Yazdanshenas, Hamed Dehghanan, Amir Safari Moghadam

Abstract  
1- INTRODUCTION
Implementing the strategy is one of the most significant and challenging topics for organizations and leaders. Successful organizational change can transform the organization's business, and interest in studying in this field, especially taking care of the meaning model, is increasing. Many failures are caused by paying attention to secondary results and not paying enough attention to the main cause. Employees are one of the most important factors to be considered in the strategy implementation process. The construction of meaning plays a critical role in employees' response (resistance, acceptance, or cooperation) to the new strategy. This reaction is of behavioral and cognitive type and is rooted in the employees' understanding. Lewin's 3-stage approach is accepted by Many organizational change experts. Many models of changing the meaning construction suggest that the process of changing the meaning in the minds of employees may also consist of these three stages of Lewin; First, managers destroy the old meaning construction of the organizational reality in the minds of employees, then they create a new meaning construction, and finally, they consolidate the new meaning construction (refreezzing). This article takes a look at the process of changing the meaning-making in the minds of employees by comparing it with Levin's model. The major difference between this article and some others in this field is its focus on two points. First, in this article, only certain types of specific meanings of discoursive activity are emphasized, and at the same time, it refers more to how the manager influences the meaning change process.
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
In the past, articles have mostly looked at the meaning-making of employees by managers with a negative approach. Therefore, in this view, any sense-making of employees, such as the meaning they give to change, was considered a resistant force. Leaders were only seeking to break down the previous meaning structure of the employees. More recent studies have shown that the perception of employees, which is rooted in the past and the meaning construction of employees, is not only an obstacle to change but can also act as an effecting factor in implementing a new strategy. The change in the meaning structure of employees can be a factor in the success of the change.
 
3- METHODOLOGY
Narrative and thematic analysis methods were used to analyze data to investigate the change in the meaning construction. Thematic analysis was nested in the narrative analysis method as a tool for better data analysis. The narrative analysis makes it possible to investigate the meanings of the manager in their discursive activities, and the thematic analysis identifies the themes of the narrations. The main focus in this case was on changing the meaning construction, and the impact of discoursive activities on this issue was considered more. Narrative analysis takes a deeper look at how the content of discourse activity is used and refers specifically to how experiences and issues are interpreted. Thematic analysis is a method for data analysis to understand the factors affecting the identification of criteria for understanding interpretations of employees.
 
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
In the narrative analysis, the narrations that contained many different meaning units were identified. The leader tries to change the employees' meaning construction using these narratives. These narrations are usually mentioned in several meetings and periods. In the following, all narrations were analyzed by thematic analysis. To categorize themes and better understand the relationship between discursive activity and meaning construction, pay more attention to more resonant themes. This process was stopped when extracting new themes was no longer possible. In the end, with a theory-oriented point of view, coding was done based on specific theories and hypotheses. There are three main axes explicit from Lewin's change model. The themes of identification are placed around these axes. In the first step, discursive activities seemed to be focused most on expressing the defects in the existing situation. This concept is repeated in different ways, even in disappeared businesses. Finally, the focus was on the desired goal and refreezing new conditions.
 
 
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
In this study, by reviewing and summarizing the findings, we came across several fundamental approaches: the first and most important approach, which was the main research question, referred to the analysis of the change process in the employees' meaning construction and its compliance with Levine's model. In Levin's model, first, the defrosting process occurs by attacking the existing conditions, then the change phase, and finally, stabilization and refreezing occur. In the defrosting stage, measures like identifying the need for change, specifying what needs to be changed, encouraging the employees to change old behaviors, ensuring the full support of senior managers for the change, and paying attention to understanding concerns and doubts. Narratives that refer to the current situation's lack of appropriate response to new environmental changes and consider the existing jobs as inferior or the existing structure as inefficient are included in this section. It seems that after studying the time course of narrations and the number of their repetitions in these intervals, it is possible to present such a picture of it. In other words, narratives and themes that try to attack the existing meanings and systems of employees are placed in this stage. The second approach is that the discursive activities happening in the direction of change in the meaning construction are not separate phases and sometimes act together. Maybe this is due to the difference in the capacity of people to change. For example, a group needs more repetition and meditation to change its meaning construction.

Presenting a Recruitment and Utilization Model for Employees Based on Green Human Resource Management in the National Iranian Tanker Company

Volume 18, Spring & Summer 2026, July 2026

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.94975.1748

Niusha Hellatabadi, Mojtaba Amiri, Mahdi Kheirandish

Abstract Green Human Resource Management (GHRM), as a modern approach in recent decades, has increasingly attracted the attention of researchers and managers with the aim of integrating environmental considerations into human resource processes. This approach, by enhancing employees’ environmental awareness, strengthening organizational commitment to social responsibility, and institutionalizing a culture of sustainability, paves the way for achieving long-term and responsible performance. In Iran, given the strategic role of the oil industry and the key position of the National Iranian Tanker Company (NITC) in the energy supply chain, designing and localizing a model for green recruitment and employment holds particular importance. This study aimed to identify the key factors influencing green recruitment and employment and to explain their mechanisms of impact on organizational sustainability. The research is applied–developmental in nature and was designed with a qualitative approach based on thematic analysis. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews with 20 academic experts and human resource managers and analyzed using MAXQDA 20 software. Findings revealed that green recruitment and employment, as a foundational construct, enhance sustainable organizational performance through strengthening green management and a meritocratic culture, as well as mechanisms such as alignment with environmental values, customer orientation, empowerment, and social responsibility. Moreover, a green performance management system, by integrating environmental indicators and continuous feedback, creates a sustainable competitive advantage. Despite limitations such as focusing on a single organization and the qualitative nature of the research, this study provides a conceptual framework for future quantitative investigations. It is recommended that policymakers develop standardized GHRM guidelines to facilitate its implementation in key industries and thereby pave the way toward achieving organizational sustainability.

The effect of functional conflict and knowledge sharing on marketing capabilities moderated by communication quality and conflict intensity

Volume 13, Autumn & Winter 2022, February 2022, Pages 65-90

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2021.70306.1111

masumeh arabshahi, Raha Tamani

Abstract  
INTRODUCTION

Nowadays, organizations have to be ready to react to the increasingly competitive environment in order to understand and meet the customers’ needs and prevent them from switchover to rivals. Therefore, many organizations have utilized strategies that make them capable of improving marketing capabilities. according to the above mentioned, the aim of the present study is to investigate the effect of functional conflict and knowledge sharing on marketing capabilities as well as the moderating effect of communication quality and conflict intensity in the 5-star darvishi hotel.
 

THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK

Conflict is the outcome of political behaviors. functional or good conflict can be beneficial for the organization by inspiring the organization’s innovation and increasing its potential to face the customers’ ever-changing needs. Functional conflicts are, in fact, the differences among viewpoints and can transform the tacit knowledge into explicit knowledge and help the knowledge to be shared more and more effectively. Conflict management is a positive indicator of an organization’s health. Moreover, establishing communication of high quality may affect the type and intensity of conflict and, also, can play an important role in knowledge sharing desirability. The more conflict intensity and qualified communication, the more the effect of functional conflict on knowledge sharing will be.

METHODOLOGY

The current research is an applied study in terms of purpose, and it is a descriptive survey in terms of the data collection method. The statistical population was comprised of 335 employees of darvishi hotel among which 179 people were selected by conducting stratified random sampling. a pre-made questionnaire was used to gather field data. The obtained data was analyzed by conducting partial least squares structural equation modeling in smartpls software.
 

RESULTS & DISCUSSION

Research results showed that functional conflict has a positive and significant effect on knowledge sharing. the moderating effects of conflict intensity and communication quality on the relationship between functional conflict and knowledge sharing were also confirmed. Furthermore, the results indicated that knowledge sharing has a positive and significant effect on responsiveness and innovation capability. also, the moderating role of communication quality on the association of knowledge sharing with responsiveness and innovation capability was statistically confirmed.
 

DISCUSSION & CONCLUSION

According to research findings, if the organization’s managers determine and eliminate the obstacles of knowledge sharing and its employees transform tacit knowledge into explicit knowledge the conflict between the staff will change from destructive to functional. by enhancing teamwork through encouragement and motivation, managers can create and expand sympathy among staff which leads to enhancing the quality of communication and, consequently, improving knowledge-sharing. Today managers are well aware of the fact that owning a competitive advantage depends on empowering the organization’s responsiveness to customer and environmental needs. therefore, documenting the staff experiences and knowledge and clever planning lead to competitive advantage and, consequently, improve the organization’s functional performance.

Investigating the Drivers of Managers’ Conspiracy Illusion in public Organizations using the Method of Interpretive Structural

Volume 13, Spring & summer 2021, September 2021, Pages 85-108

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2021.68044.1010

fattah sharifzadeh, mahdieh vishlaghi

Abstract 1- INTRODUCTION The illusion of conspiracy in managers makes them think that employees are secretly and maliciously seeking to conspire and achieve selfish goals, which leads to increased pessimism about employees and organizational trauma. Therefore, identifying the factors affecting the delusion of managers in state organizations and eliminating them leads to facilitating the path of organizational development and transformation. Accordingly, the purpose of the present study is to identify and level the drivers of the conspiracy illusion of managers. 2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK The illusion of conspiracy has been described as a conspiracy carried out by a number of powerful agents to achieve destructive goals. conspiracy theories have symptoms such as anomie, distrust of authority, political pessimism, machiavellianism, and disability. conspiracy theories can change the way people think about social events. the illusion of conspiracy occurs in conditions of uncertainty, and due to low access to accurate information people are more likely to have the illusion of conspiracy. factors such as openness and intellectual curiosity, inclination to new ideas, and effective communication are among the factors that reduce the illusion of organizational conspiracy. the illusion of organizational conspiracy can be expressed for powerful groups in the workplace (managers) who seek to achieve goals that are done in secret. managers may deliberately hire or fire their preferred candidate. the illusion of conspiracy in organizations leads to the dismissal of employees and key members of the organization. organizations as social institutions are among the most important places for the formation of conspiracy theories, and conspiracy theories, in addition to the destructive effects they will have on the organization, also have harmful effects on society. 3- METHODOLOGY                                                                                                      The present research is a descriptive survey in terms of data collection, and it is an applied study in terms of purpose. it was conducted in two steps. in the first step, using the qualitative content analysis method, the factors affecting the illusion of organizational conspiracy were identified and extracted through semi-structured interviews with 15 professors of management and psychology. the validity and reliability of the interviews were confirmed by the method of relative content validity and the kappa cohen index, respectively. coding of interviews using atlas software led to the identification of 11 drivers in the formation of conspiracy theories. in the second step, in order to level the identified drivers, the opinions of 26 senior managers of public organizations located in the province of west azerbaijan were obtained using a questionnaire distributed based on purposive sampling method and analyzed by structural equation modeling. the validity and reliability of the questionnaire were confirmed by content validity and test-post-test methods, respectively. 4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION Encryption of interview data led to the identification of 11 drivers, cultural weakness, lack of transparency, norm-breaking, incompetence, political behavior, conscientious leadership style, dysfunctional communication, poor performance, corruption, power gap, and managerial weakness. in the interpretive structural model, the interrelationships and influence between the criteria of different levels were well shown, which leads to a better understanding of the decision-making space by managers. the modeling performed with an interpretive structural approach has classified the identified propulsions into six levels. the sixth level is related to the most effective drivers and the first level is related to the most effective drivers. according to the micmac matrix, the results indicate that there is no criterion in the autonomous sector, and this indicates that among the factors affecting the conspiracy illusion, there is no factor that does not affect the conspiracy illusion, and all factors are effective. in the field of influence, there is only a conscientious leadership style, which has low dependence and high influence. in the dependency sector, where the dependency rate is high and there is weak influence, the variables of non-transparency, inefficient communication, and managerial weakness are located. in the link section, which is high dependency and influence, there are variables of cultural weakness, norm-breaking, meritocracy, political behaviors, poor performance, power distance, and corruption meaning that they have high influence and power in terms of dependence. 5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS The illusion of conspiracy in the managers of organizations leads to a kind of contradiction, paranoia, pessimism, and conflicts that cause irreparable damage to the organization. according to the findings of the research at the sixth level, cultural weakness and managerial weakness have had the greatest impact compared to other factors, however, cultural weakness has been the most influential factor. at the fifth level of the model is corruption, which is somehow affected by cultural weakness and managerial weakness. at the fourth level, there is a conscientious leadership style and distance from power and undesirable performance, which is influenced by cultural weakness, poor management, and corruption in organizations. at the third level is norm-breaking, which is influenced by conscientious leadership style, distance from power, and undesirable performance. in the second level, there is a lack of meritocracy in political behaviors and games, and in the first level, there is a lack of transparency and inefficient communication, which is due to the lack of transparency of information and procedures, as well as inefficient communication between managers and employees. the illusion of conspiracy increases in managers. in this regard, it is suggested that the culture of participation and support be replaced, which paves the way for more space for the presentation of views and self-openness of employees. increasing organizational competencies through the implementation of training courses, holding think tanks, and using the methods of the nominal and delphi groups can lead to an increase in knowledge, experience, and managerial abilities. reducing corruption and the need to comply with organizational norms leads to unity and integrity of members of the organization. transparency in organizational affairs and accountability for performance can reduce the illusion of conspiracy. in this regard, they should pay attention to the factors that create the illusion of conspiracy of managers in organizations and try to weaken these factors in order to achieve a moral organization with a healthy atmosphere.

Investigating the Effect of Corporate Culture on the Performance of SMEs in Iran and Iraq with Regard to the Mediating Role of Entrepreneurship and the Moderating Role of National Culture

Volume 14, Spring & summer 2022, September 2022, Pages 85-122

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2021.70254.1108

Mahmood Abdulla, Yaghoob Maharati, Gholamreza Malekzadeh, Alireza Khorakian

Abstract  
1- INTRODUCTION
Small and medium-sized companies are a primary source for creating jobs and economic growth in developing countries, which cause economic diversification and the development of the private sector in these countries. According to the statistics of the European Economic Cooperation and Development Organization, small and medium enterprises comprise more than 95% of the business in the member countries of this organization. The share of these companies in the employment of member countries of the European Economic Cooperation and Development Organization is around 60 to 70 percent. In advanced countries such as Japan and Germany, the share of small and medium enterprises in the GDP is more than 50%, and in developing countries such as Thailand, it is 38%. In Iran, 94% of economic enterprises are small and medium type, and their share in GDP is 39%. 27683 (82%) of the 34252 operational industrial units in Iran's industrial states are active, including 9726 units with a capacity of less than 50%, 9597 units with a capacity between 50% and 70%, and 8360 units with a capacity of more than 70%. They have a percentage of activity.
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Cameron and Quinn pay attention to the ethnic culture in the degree of intimacy between family members in the work environment. Ethnic culture is characterized by loyalty, ethics, commitment, traditionality, cooperation, teamwork, participation, awareness and personal development. Adhocracy culture is a dynamic, entrepreneurial, innovative and creative structure in the work environment. This culture focuses on the development of new products and services, adaptability, growth, Change, productivity, efficiency and experientialism are emphasized. Market culture is considered as a result-oriented culture in the workplace with an emphasis on winning, surpassing the competition, insisting on stock prices and market relations. The formality and structuring of positions and procedures, well-defined processes and smooth-moving organizations are often considered as the main characteristics of hierarchical culture.
 
3- METHODOLOGY
The questionnaire’s face validity was established through evaluating the opinions of management professors and SMEs’ managers, and confirmatory factor analysis confirmed its construct validity. The Cronbach’s alphas of greater than 0.70 also confirmed the questionnaire’s reliability. Data gathered from the managers of SMEs was analyzed by conducting structural equation modeling.
 
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
Examining the effect of four types of culture on performance also showed that the effect of group culture is insignificant and the effect of three types of adhocracies, hierarchy and market culture on performance is significant, although the effect of hierarchy culture on performance is negative and the effect of adhocracy and market culture is positive. The result of the non-significant effect of ethnic culture on performance is inconsistent with the research results of prior researches. The results of their research indicate a positive and significant effect of group culture on performance.
 
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Considering that the results of this research show that different types of corporate culture have an effect on the tendency to entrepreneurship and performance, therefore managers who want to increase this tendency should evaluate their organizational culture and adapt them accordingly. It is the responsibility of senior management to disseminate, promote, maintain or change organizational culture.

Designing and explaining a comprehensive model for the conceptual expanding of team building coaching in emerging and knowledge-based companies

Volume 17, Spring&Summer2025, August 2025, Pages 92-123

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.91520.1652

Azadeh Eftekhar, Qumars Ahmadi, Reza Salehi, Yaaghoub Ahmadi

Abstract This research was conducted with the aim of designing and explaining a comprehensive model for conceptual development of team building coaching in start-up and knowledge-based companies. This research is applied in terms of its purpose, exploratory in terms of its approach, and mixed (qualitative-quantitative) in terms of its data analysis. In the qualitative phase of the research, a group of experts including university professors, senior managers of start-up and knowledge-based companies, and experienced human resources consultants were considered as the statistical population. In this phase, 12 experts were selected using purposive sampling. The main data collection tool in the qualitative phase of the research was in-depth and semi-structured interviews with experts. In the qualitative phase of the research, the data obtained from the interviews were analyzed based on the theme analysis method. In the quantitative phase, 108 managers were considered as the population. The validity and reliability of this questionnaire were examined and confirmed by various methods. In the quantitative phase of the research, SPSS and Smart PLS software were used to conduct descriptive and inferential analyses. Finally, the research results led to the design of a comprehensive model for conceptual development of team building coaching in start-up and knowledge-based companies in the form of 6 main themes and 21 sub-themes. Based on the obtained model, organizational and environmental factors as the main drivers have an impact on the strategic and promoting factors of team building coaching, and these factors also lead to the realization of team building coaching, and ultimately a series of individual and organizational outcomes will be achieved.

Examining the Impact of Strategic Leadership on Sustainable Competitive Advantage Mediated by Innovation Ambidexterity and Human Capital

Volume 15, Spring & summer 2023, September 2023, Pages 99-125

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2023.72474.1360

Mohammad Sadegh Akbari Nooghabi, Azar Kaffashpoor, Mahdi Bahrami, Sajad Pourkian

Abstract  
1- INTRODUCTION
The current research aims to investigate the effect of strategic leadership on the ability to create sustainable competitive advantage. Moreover, it examines the mediating role of human capital and innovation ambidexterity. The target population of the research is enterprises operating in the growth center of Ferdowsi University of Mashhad.
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Strategic leadership is the process of directing strategic plans and ensuring their satisfactory implementation, the objective of which is to succeed the organization in the long term. Leadership is considered one of the most important duties and roles of a manager. The importance of this task is high such that some scholars relate a manager's success to their ability to direct human resources. Human capital is a set of management skills such as creativity, problem-solving ability, and leadership embedded in the organization's employees. Human capital is a constitution of all potential and actual capabilities of employees that can be strengthened with proper investment. The ability of an organization to simultaneously discover innovative opportunities and implement innovation is a contradiction called innovation ambidexterity. Sustainable competitive advantage is defined as higher-than-normal returns associated with the performance and expectations of the capital market.
 
3- METHODOLOGY
The current research is a positivist study in terms of paradigm, inductive in terms of approach, practical in terms of purpose, descriptive-analytical in terms of method, and quantitative in terms of data and research design. The target population of this research is comprised of 110 enterprises at the growth center of Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, from which 86 were sampled with the simple random method. Thus, its level of analysis is organizational. Needed data was collected by distributing a written questionnaire, whose reliability was affirmed using Cronbach's alpha and composite reliability coefficient. To assess the questionnaire's validity, a confirmatory factor analysis was conducted and evaluated in terms of both convergence and divergence. The collected data was analyzed by conducting a structural equation modeling in SmartPLS software.
 
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
Research results confirmed all its hypotheses and indicated that strategic leadership has a direct positive significant effect on sustainable competitive advantage. Additionally, it affects sustainable competitive advantage indirectly through human capital and innovation ambidexterity.
 
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Practical and research implications are presented as follows.

It is suggested that enterprises hold a workshop for their managers to teach important points of strategic leadership and the art of influencing others. It is suggested that managers redefine the organizational goals and vision based on the current conditions of the environment, redesign the organizational structure according to new goals and conditions, organize training programs for employees to develop their human capital, design programs to improve moral values in the organization; enhance the organizational culture by arranging individual and group counseling meetings for employees and managers.
It is suggested that managers establish a research and development center, establish a closer and more organized relationship with university professors in order to use new knowledge and transform it into new technologies, and establish an industry-university liaison office. Company managers are advised to give priority to hiring and employing creative and innovative employees. Also, for any innovation presented by the employees that leads to the creation of a creative product or service, allocate a percentage of the sales profit to encourage them.
Considering the dramatic difference between the enterprises in the growth center regarding age, market size, type of activity, growth stage, number of employees, and other factors, it is suggested to approach them differently and study these enterprises in separate and more specialized categories.
Since several factors may influence the relationship between strategic leadership and sustainable competitive advantage, according to a review of the research literature as well as field observations, it is suggested to consider mediators such as knowledge capital, organizational culture, brand reputation, strategic flexibility, business intelligence, etc.
The research reached a big difference between humanities and non-humanities growth center companies (including engineering, agriculture, basic sciences, veterinary medicine, and sports sciences). Accordingly, it is suggested to conduct separate research on them for a more detailed investigation.

Explaining the Enabling Factors of Communication Maturity in Iran's Government Organizations

Volume 16, Spring&Summer2024, July 2024, Pages 100-126

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.87047.1552

Mansour Rahmani, Masoud Bastami, Soleiman Ahmadzadeh

Abstract 1- INTRODUCTION
Recent studies have used the maturity concept to assess organizations' progress in various fields. Communication maturity within organizations reflects the level of development in perceptions and practices related to organizational communication. Specifically, this concept refers to the ability of managers to identify challenges and facilitate the path toward communications in line with organizational success. It also refers to a deep understanding of interpersonal and organizational relationships. Previous studies on organizations have shown that attitudes, beliefs, values, ideologies, and diverse experiences can affect communication. Therefore, managers of organizations need to be familiar with different communication approaches to select one or a combination of them to achieve communication maturity. Theories such as excellence theory and institutional theory have approached effective organizational communication. For instance, Excellence Theory seeks to identify the characteristics of efficient public relations and its impact on organizational performance. Many studies have examined and demonstrated the positive outcomes of effective organizational communication such as increased productivity, decreased costs, and improved quality of products and services. In this context, communication competence has been considered a key element in achieving organizational success. Numerous studies on communication maturity models mostly for European organizations have focused on providing evaluation models and less paid attention to identifying its enabling factors. Particularly, in Iran, no comprehensive research has been conducted on this subject so far.
 
2- METHODOLOGY
This research aims to identify the enabling factors of communication maturity in Iranian governmental organizations. In terms of nature, this is an exploratory study, employing a qualitative approach with a thematic analysis as its strategy. This analysis strategy is a process that transforms scattered data into meaningful patterns. Using snowball sampling, 16 semi-structured interviews were conducted with academic and organizational experts until reaching theoretical saturation. Following the 6-step process of Braun and Clarke’s method, the collected data was analyzed using MAXQDA software.
 
3- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
Research findings indicated that communication maturity in Iranian governmental organizations depends on four main components as driving forces or enablers: communication capability, organizational factors, and soft and hard human resources factors. The communication capability component includes factors such as message simplicity, the manner of presenting and understanding the message, the legitimacy of the message sender, and the communication environment. Communication transparency and organizational structure, trust, and policies were identified as factors following the organizational component, contributing to a healthy and efficient communication environment and processes. Time management, communication competence, adaptability, flexibility, employee attitudes, and job satisfaction fall into the soft human resources component, which directly influences the quality of internal communication. The hard human resources component includes the factors of budget and facilities, technical and perceptual skills, and network management. The availability of technical infrastructure and sufficient finance is of great importance for enhancing communication networks in organizations.
 
4- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Based on the results of this research, communication maturity in Iranian governmental organizations depends on organizational and individual factors. The main identified components are critical for strengthening organizational communication and enhancing communication maturity. Given the importance of communication in organizational success, attention to these factors can contribute to improved organizational performance and increased productivity. This research also highlights the need for further studies on developing communication maturity evaluation models in Iranian organizations.

Developing an Organizational Trust Model Using Grounded Theory

Volume 16, Autumn&Winter2025, January 2025, Pages 107-156

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.86226.1530

Arezoosadat Hashemiamin, Gholamreza Malekzadeh, Yaghoob Maharati

Abstract INTRODUCTION

Organizational trust is one of the most important factors that shape the organization's vision, mission, culture, and values. It originates in employees' evaluations regarding the issue of whether the organization has the authority to respond to its goals and responsibilities and adheres to the accepted ethical principles in its communication with the stakeholders. The problem of organizational trust in Iranian organizations is more visible due to the lack of a model that fits the country's culture and background. The lack of an organizational trust model has created many problems in government organizations. Government organizations are among the organizations that play an important role in the country. These organizations have a tremendous impact on the development of society and people's well-being by making key decisions, making policies, planning, providing essential services, etc. The absence of a native model of organizational trust has led to weak work performance and organizational commitment of the workforce in Iran's government organizations; also, leading employees do not perform their assigned duties well, and have low motivation, work relationships, and job satisfaction. Therefore, due to the vital role of organizational trust in government organizations and the importance of these organizations in society, the present research aim is to present the model of organizational trust in government organizations, with a specialized and comprehensive examination of organizational trust in Khorasan Razavi’s government organizations.
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Trust in organizations is divided into individual, interpersonal, and organizational trust. Organizational trust is a multi-level phenomenon that evaluates organization members in conjunction with organization systems to respond to its goals and responsibilities and adhere to accepted ethical principles in communication with its beneficiaries. Although some previous research has examined trust in the organization, especially interpersonal trust, research that specifically focuses on organizational trust, the employees’ trust toward the organization, is rarely seen, and the lack of an organizational trust model, especially in Iranian organizations, has caused numerous problems.
 
3- METHODOLOGY
This is qualitative research based on the grounded theory with a systematic approach. The theoretical saturation criterion was achieved after conducting 17 semi-structured interviews with government organizations' experts. Data analysis was done based on coding processes and using MAXQDA software. To ensure the validity and increase the credibility of the research, the criteria provided by Guba and Lincoln (1994) and to evaluate its strength, the four criteria of appropriateness, relevance, applicability, and modifiability of Strauss and Corbin (1998) were used.
 
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
In addition to confirming the results of previous research, this research achieved new findings. Based on these findings, organizational trust in government organizations is created from reliability and predictability based on the causes of trust-building management, trust-building organization, and trust-building employees. Moreover, organizational trust affects the strategy implementation such as ethics-orientation, interactions, regulations, and processes. The consequences of these strategies include enhancing performance regarding the employees' psychological well-being improvement and the organization's productivity. Also, they improve the stakeholders' satisfaction, including the people's satisfaction and the organization's legitimacy. The context of the effective application of these strategies is the internal environment including the atmosphere and physical environment of the organization and the external environment, including the political and economic conditions and national culture. In the meantime, the influence of intervenors, such as organizational conformity and demographic components of the organization on the effectiveness of these strategies should not be ignored.
 
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Considering that the present research dealt with the statistics of the organizational trust model in government organizations and provided outputs in the field of causes, consequences, strategies, context, and intervenors of organizational trust; It can be acknowledged that the proposed model can be used in organizations, especially public ones, as a suitable guide for promoting and developing organizational trust. Managers can thus strengthen employees’ trust in the organization.

The role of boundary spanning in organizational innovation: A meta-analysis approaches

Volume 15, Autumn & Winter 2024, February 2024, Pages 114-146

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.85077.1502

Saeid Norollahee, Siroos Ghanbari

Abstract  
1- INTRODUCTION
To acquire innovations produced by universities and higher education institutions, organizations can use the strategy of boundary-spanning to meet their needs. The results of the previous research also indicate the effect of boundary spanning on organizational innovation. Based on this, it is possible to develop innovation in the industry by using boundary spanning. On the other hand, from 2015 to 2023, several researches have been conducted and published regarding the positive impact of boundary spanning on organizational innovation in different countries. By analyzing and summarizing the findings of previous studies by making sure of the relationship between the two considered variables and by making sure of the accuracy of the current findings, it is possible to provide solutions to improve the boundary spanning between industry and university as well as to improve the effect of boundary spanning on organizational innovation. Therefore, the primary question of the research is to what extent does the boundary spanning affect organizational innovation?
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
As a description of boundary spanning in the field of organizational innovations, Tashman expanded the communication boundaries that are conceptual and linguistic differences in a laboratory environment, between the laboratory and other parts of the organization, and between different organizations. To increase the level of interaction and participation between industry and university and to take advantage of the innovations created in universities and higher education institutions, there is a need to develop the relationship between industry and university and acquire knowledge resources through the frontier strategy. In bridging and establishing inter-institutional communication and connecting separate groups, these people face boundaries and should cross these boundaries and obstacles and communicate with organizations outside the borders. Accordingly, boundary spanning helps the universities share scientific and technical information, and the industry acquire and understand academic innovations. Generally, boundary spanning is an effective strategy for developing the university-industry relationship to cultivate, share, and apply organizational innovations. Industries and companies are less willing to invest in research and development due to the high cost of complex laboratory equipment, the difficulty of access to international research and development centers, the risks associated with innovation, and the investment limitations. Hence, they are interested in getting the latest innovations in knowledge through higher education institutions. For industry-university collaboration to thrive, companies must learn to operate outside their organizational boundaries and develop their capabilities to interact and collaborate with partners with different characteristics.
3- METHODOLOGY
In terms of its purpose, the current research is an applied study, and by its meta-analysis method, it is considered a quantitative study. In this research, the investigated community was the research studies published in English about the role of boundary spanning in organizational innovation from 2015 to 2023. In the first stage, 189 studies regarding the relationship between boundary-spanning and organizational innovation were selected from various databases. Then, 33 duplicate articles indexed in different databases were identified and removed. The number of 156 articles was identified for title and abstract review. By examining the titles and abstracts of all identified articles, 129 articles were excluded from the article review process due to lack of relevance to the research topic and lack of inclusion criteria. Therefore, 27 articles were selected for full review. By examining the remaining articles more closely and studying their results, 18 were picked for meta-analysis.
 
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
The findings showed that the average effect of boundary-spanning (random mixed effects) on organizational innovation equals 0.347. Considering that this effect size (0.347) is within the confidence range, it should be said that boundary spanning affects innovation. The obtained point estimate (0.347), based on Cohen's criterion, indicates an effect in the upper medium range. In general, boundary-spanning moderately affected organizational innovation.
 
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
In general, innovation is a competitive advantage for organizations and industries, and innovative organizations can compete with other competitors and maintain the survival of their organization. Companies and organizations will be removed from the competition scene if they cannot achieve innovation to meet the new needs of society and the market. One of the ways to achieve innovation is the interaction of industry and university in the form of boundary-spanning activities. In this way, industries can obtain new academic knowledge innovations to develop new products and services to satisfy the market needs. Boundary-spanning operations can facilitate disseminating the innovation produced in universities for industry use. Therefore, it is suggested that to acquire and develop innovations produced in universities and scientific institutions, organizations and industries should turn to boundary-spanning and use boundary-spanning strategies in developing cooperation with universities.

The Model of Innovative Social Banking Based on Digital Transformation in Iran's Banking Industry

Volume 14, Autumn & Winter 2023, February 2023, Pages 121-149

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2023.79121.1358

Ali Mahmoodi, Abbas Khamseh, Mehrdad Hosseini Shakib

Abstract  
1- INTRODUCTION
In recent years, the development of information and communication technology infrastructures, has equipped banks with online information and communication resources and led them from traditional space to a banking platform based on centralized and multi-branch infrastructures. Relying on promotion of technology and data orientation, social banking has provided a new space to the country's banking industry. Adopting a digital transformation approach, the current research is to identify factors affecting the innovation process of social banking.
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
According to research institutes, digital innovations in the banking industry have created various opportunities and threats for banks. These institutions introduce digital transformation as a double-edged sword, one side of which will increase the bank's profitability by creating a competitive advantage and reducing costs. On the other hand, with the empowerment of competitors and the pressure to reduce the profit margin and increase some operational risks, it may lead to a decrease in profitability. In the path of digital transformation and implementation plans, it is necessary to be realistic and then proceed to develop a strategy and carry out the necessary activities. One of the major challenges of digital transformation is that we cannot reach the highest level of digital maturity at once and should go through a series of intermediate steps. In the field of fintech digital transformation, open banking and mobile technology are of great importance and are considered as the main drivers of the development and realization of digital transformation.
 
3- METHODOLOGY
In this research, fuzzy Delphi method has identified and prioritized the factors affecting innovation process in social banking with an approach to digital transformation. This was accomplished based on 377 questionnaires. To analyze the data and to check the research model fitness, structural equation modeling was conducted in Amos software. The opinion of industry experts confirmed the validity of the questionnaire, and its reliability was confirmed by Cronbach's alpha coefficients of greater than 0.7.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
The results showed that 36 out of 43 indicators affect the innovation process of social banking in the form of six distinct factors. Based on obtained results with a digital transformation approach, the key affecting factors were as follows respectively (in terms of their effect size): digital transformation infrastructure, laws and policies, innovative approach, banking industry structure, security, and social factors.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Digital transformation infrastructure: Developing countries such as Iran must take the necessary local measures to implement the appropriate technical infrastructure for electronic commerce. For the successful implementation of digital transformation, banks need strong infrastructures to support data.
Laws and policies: Regarding digital transformations, legislators and upper bodies can implement and facilitate the process of digital transformation by formulating laws in the field of entrepreneurship.
Innovative approach: The digital economy creates unique opportunities for entrepreneurs who have an innovative approach to the environment and new entrepreneurial activities.
Banking industry structure: Customers prefer personalized services. Banks, to be successful, should switch to platforms that can offer a variety of capabilities to a larger ecosystem of specialized providers.
Security: Electronic banking, like any other Internet-based service, is one of the favorite fields for cybercriminals. Maintaining information security is one of the important topics of electronic commerce and banking.
Social factors: Digital banking allows customers to take advantage of IT benefits when using their banking processes that increase their intention to use online banking.
Based on research results, the following practical suggestions are presented to the banking industry managers and practitioners:

Government institutions and legislators are suggested to formulate and implement new laws and regulations for the effective use of technology in this industry.
Banks should identify and exploit the opportunities existing in the environment by creating a strong expert group.
Banks should utilize powerful support systems to protect information and customers.
Banks should change their organizational structure for deploying new technology.
Banks should empower their employees by exploiting up-to-date knowledge based on information technology.
Managers should digitize the banks' environment and climate to internalize digital procedures in employees' habits and behaviors.

Investigating the effect of Spiritual Leadership on Participation in Religious Tourism Events with the mediation of Servant Behavior and the moderation of Demographic Characteristics of Servants

Volume 17, Autumn 2025 and Winter 2026, December 2025

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.93059.1710

Elham Kasraee, Azar Kaffashpoor, Mohammad Sadegh Akbari Nooghabi, Ali Moeenfard

Abstract The presence of over 20 million annual pilgrims at the Razavi Holy Shrine underscores the necessity of understanding the behavioral mechanisms of its servants. This research, which focuses on the "Naeem Rezvan" unit, seeks to elucidate how the "Spiritual Leadership" of managers, through "Servant Behavior," enhances the "Participation in Religious Tourism Events" among the servants. The study is applied in nature concerning its objectives and descriptive-analytical in methodology. The statistical population comprised 190 active female servants, from which 123 were selected through simple random sampling. Data were gathered utilizing three standardized questionnaires. The reliability of the instruments was verified using Cronbach's alpha coefficient, while construct validity was established through confirmatory factor analysis. Structural Equation Modeling was employed to test the hypotheses. The results indicated that Spiritual Leadership directly fortifies Servant Behavior and Participation in Religious Events. Furthermore, Servant Behavior significantly contributes to increased Participation. Notably, the indirect effect of Spiritual Leadership on Participation, mediated by Servant Behavior, was found to be significant. However, demographic characteristics did not exhibit a significant moderating effect. The findings suggest that enhancing the dimensions of inspirational vision, hope/faith, and altruistic love within the leadership style may bolster the servant spirit and the level of active participation among the servants. Consequently, it is recommended that psychological empowerment programs and training in empathy skills be prioritized for shrine managers. Additionally, criteria regarding Servant Behavior should be integrated into the performance evaluation of the servants.

Designing a Digital Transformation Leadership Model in ICT Companies Using Grounded Theory

Volume 18, Spring & Summer 2026, July 2026

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2026.96229.1778

Amir Nikkar, Atefeh Farazmand

Abstract Nowadays the necessity of organizations synchronization with digital transformation and cultivating digital leaders has been proved. Furthermore in recent years a new leadership style as digital transformation leadership which pertains to human and social dimensions of digital transformation has been proposed and managers lack of awareness about this leadership style is considered one of the most important challenges in success and growth path of ICT companies. The main purpose of this study is to design a digital transformation leadership model in ICT companies through qualitative research method based on grounded theory. Accordingly 15 experts with scientific background and managerial experiences related to the field of digital transformation leadership in ICT companies were selected as the contributors through purposive sampling. Furthermore data collection was obtained through semi-structured. Also Data analysis was performed through three stages including open coding, axial coding and selective coding based on Strauss and Corbin systematic approach and to ensure the validity and credibility of the research, Lincoln and Guba criteria were used. The analysis of results reveals that in the digital transformation leadership model in ICT companies, causal conditions include: leaders’ traits; contextual conditions include: underlying factors and environmental factors; phenomenon includes: digital transformation leadership; intervening conditions include: organizational learning, organizational cohesion, supportive atmosphere and competency-based approach; strategies include: digital culture development and digital skills development; consequences include: organizational achievements encompassing increasing organizational productivity and organizational agility and national achievements encompassing economic and social effects.

Providing a framework for the acquisition of experts' tacit knowledge to identify environmental opportunities and threats

Volume 13, Autumn & Winter 2022, February 2022, Pages 91-124

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2021.31138.0

naser motahari farimani, azam modares, niloofar jahanara

Abstract
1- INTRODUCTION
The topic of knowledge management is of the most important ones for today’s companies and organizations. Today's competitive world has forced organizations to work harder to succeed and survive in competition and manage their knowledge more effectively. Tacit knowledge can be considered as a set of experiences, skills, work perspectives, and value and mental systems within the individual that is gained through professional and personal experiences. Examining the external environment and recognizing the factors of this environment to take advantage of opportunities and avoid threats is seriously related to the method of tacit knowledge acquisition. Therefore, the acquisition of tacit knowledge of experts is one of the key needs for gaining a competitive advantage and the organization’s success. In doing so, it is necessary to identify the experts’ mental patterns, ideas, beliefs, and attitudes toward the future.
 
2-THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
While there is a lot of foreign research on environmental scanning, few domestic studies have been done on internal scanning. in the field of acquisition of experts’ tacit knowledge, have been also conducted very limited domestic studies. Foreign studies have more studied the effect of tacit knowledge acquisition on various dimensions, but not the identification of strategic factors. Therefore, the purpose of the present study is to provide a framework for acquiring the experts’ tacit knowledge to identify organizational opportunities and threats. this study is based on an interpretive approach and used content analysis as the data analysis strategy.
3- METHODOLOGY
After identifying the key categories extracted from the theoretical literature, in-depth interviews were conducted with experts, and based on the opinions expressed by the interviewees; related codes and categories were extracted. In this phase, data were analyzed by interpretive approach, which is a method for mentally interpreting the content of the interview data. in general, based on theoretical foundations and experts’ opinions and by conducting a qualitative content analysis, this study addressed the shortcomings of the current patterns for identifying the external strategic factors i.e., the organizational opportunities and threats. in the first step of the analysis, the initial or open coding was performed. To do so, the data were broken down into smaller units to shape bigger concepts. Then, all the extracted sentences and phrases were compared continuously and similar ones were grouped. After that, the specific concepts mentioned in all the sentences were extracted and assigned a specific code. in this way, the concepts were extracted from the heart of the interviews as the output of the content analysis.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
After introducing the suggested solutions and tools for each defect expressed by the experts, the current study conducted an interpretive analysis on interviews to prevent the occurrence of defects in the proposed framework. in this framework, the proposed solutions and tools were used in three stages: pre-interview, interview, and post-interview. The proposed framework introduces solutions and tools to realize the expert tacit knowledge and identify the external environment at each phase. Therefore, the tacit knowledge of experts can be achieved to identify opportunities and threats by applying the proposed framework.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
The framework proposed in the present study can be considered by organizational planners to provide better scanning of the environment and take advantage of opportunities with proper planning and full awareness of shortcomings in identifying opportunities and avoiding threats. the results indicated that there are some tools and solutions in each step of the proposed framework to eliminate the identified defects. these solutions must be implemented continuously over time as a basis for identifying opportunities and threats in regard to both the environmental monitoring and the acquisition of knowledge from experts. in the authors’ opinion, the proposed framework can be used to increase the quality of environmental scanning. For example, each stage suggests a solution to make the expert’s mind more focused on the future in line with drawing a long-term viewpoint.

Identifying the Personality Characteristics of Knowledge Workers

Volume 13, Spring & summer 2021, September 2021, Pages 109-134

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2021.67281.0

Ahmad Shaarbaf Eidgahi, Mohammad Mehraeen (Lagzian), Gholamreza Malekzadeh, Alireza Pooya

Abstract 1- INTRODUCTION
The last decade has seen many changes in the global business environment. thus, technology-driven businesses have been replaced by knowledge-based businesses. human resources are now the most important asset of organizations. but not all employees are a source of competitive advantage for organizations. rather, knowledgeable employees can create competitive advantage and added value for the organization. therefore, managers of organizations must know how to provide a suitable environment and opportunities for greater participation of knowledgeable employees in the organization, because the processes of identifying, recruiting, training, managing, and retaining are more difficult for knowledgeable staff than for other employees. organizations should know more about the personality and behavior of knowledgeable employees and develop appropriate programs to attract, train and interact with them as well as adopt necessary strategies to make them satisfied and loyal.
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
By examining most of the key factors affecting the success of knowledge management, the human factor or knowledge staff is common in most models. the term knowledge worker was first introduced by peter drucker. in his opinion, a person who works with information and develops or applies knowledge in the workplace is a knowledge worker. knowledge employees are employees who have a high level of education and experience and think about life and are mainly engaged in technical and managerial positions. on the other hand, they can have a major impact on the company and its performance. the nature of these employees requires a high level of autonomy and knowledge workers usually need to work with colleagues in similar departments, other departments, or even with employees of different organizations. knowledge workers do not repeat the same task every day, so they do not follow the instructions given to them, but use their technical and intellectual knowledge to perform tasks. personality is one of the most important factors that can be evaluated in the first call, the job seeker. because it seems difficult to pay attention to the applicant's situation in many environments and situations, a person's personality information can be used to predict his or her future behavior. the five-factor model, mbti model, and enneagram typology model are some of the most important personality models used in this study.
3- METHODOLOGY
This research was a mixed study with the interpretive philosophy in its qualitative phase (descriptive phenomenology). in the quantitative phase of the research, the pragmatism philosophy was used. the statistical population of the qualitative phase was comprised of experts such as knowledge management experts in 23 companies in Mashhad city having R&D departments. The sampling method was snowball continued to 21st interview to reach theoretical saturation. The qualitative data collection tool was semi-structured interviews and gathered data were analyzed using MAXQDA software.
 
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
Descriptive phenomenology was conducted based on the colaizzi approach. the following steps were followed: first, the interviews' content was converted from audio to text mode. at this step, a total of 270 open codes were extracted. in the next step, the codes list was referenced and some codes were integrated with each other. also, irrelevant and duplicate ones were removed from the existing list, and categories were determined based on expressions and codes extracted from previous steps. finally, eleven personality categories were extracted including introversion, conscientiousness, judgment, realism, neuroticism, incompatibility, conservatism, narcissism, thinking, self-control, and openness.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
When hiring knowledge staff, routine personality tests should be performed to select and attract people with the closest personality type to knowledge jobs. one of the most important results of this study was identifying the introversion of knowledge staff as a key personality dimension. due to the characteristics of introversion, it is appropriate to try to provide a suitable work environment for introverts such as a place for mental resting, walking, exercising, and even sleeping at work. in regard to knowledge employees' internal locus of control, managers are recommended not to externally monitor and control their work process and, instead, control their work output. in regard to the psychotic characteristics of knowledge workers, it is suggested to avoid imposing stress and work pressure on and setting a short period of time for them. in general, organizational processes should be redefined for knowledgeable employees. even if necessary, two types of processes should be implemented for knowledge and non-knowledge employees. due to the thinking characteristic, it is suggested to provide necessary conditions and situations for knowledge employees to think.

The moderating role of ethical leadership on the relationship between the organization’s external prestige and unethical pro-organizational behavior

Volume 14, Spring & summer 2022, September 2022, Pages 123-146

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2022.73834.1222

Reza Sepahvand, Meysam Jafari, Mahdieh Vishlaghi

Abstract  
1- INTRODUCTION
Behaviors can be unethical but in line with the interests of the organization. Unethical pro-organizational behavior is a creative deviant behavior that seeks to maximize the interests of the organization and stakeholders by evading the law and misleading the supervisory and upstream institutions. The external prestige of the organization is an indicator of the organization's quality and directs the behaviors of employees. The purpose of this study is to investigate the effect of the organization's external prestige on unethical pro-organizational behavior considering the moderation of ethical leadership.
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
People tend to join organizations of having valuable social features. Based on this fact, organizations try to improve their external image and prestige with internal and external stakeholders. The image of the organization is mostly influenced by the external stakeholders, so their perceptions and opinion affect the understanding and evaluation of the internal stakeholders of the organization. Organizational prestige describes the employee's perception of how external institutions look at the organization. Organizational image is of great importance for many companies because today, their work and overall existence depend on their credit from the point of view of various shareholders. To maintain the social image and the prestige of the organization, the managers and employees of the organizations may resort to actions that are not appropriate from the point of view of ethics and logic, however, they bring success and pride to the organization. Such behavior is more precisely called positive deviant behavior or unethical behavior of the organization. The positive deviation is used as a practical strategy and is an intelligent search for change and creating solutions. Therefore, with such an approach to maintain a positive and powerful image of the organization, any action that is beneficial in this direction can be used. On the other hand, the atmosphere and leadership of the organization play an important role in using ethical or unethical strategies. Ethical leaders show good values with their words and actions. In such a case, measures are followed with more sensitivity and only technical issues will not be considered. In Iran's business environment, all public and private companies are under the influence of multiple stakeholders and various regulatory organizations, and sometimes they turn to unethical behaviors to maximize their interests.
 
3- METHODOLOGY
The present research is an applied study in terms of purpose, and in terms of data collection, it is a descriptive-correlational study. The statistical population of the study was the managers and supervisors of companies under the Saipa Group. Using Cochran's formula, a sample size of 109 was selected by conducting stratified random sampling. A pre-made questionnaire was used to gather data after reaffirming reliability using Cronbach's alpha. The obtained data was analyzed in SPSS and Amos software.
 
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
According to the first hypothesis, the external prestige of the organization significantly affected unethical behaviors (beta = 0.84; t-value = 9.91). Regarding the second hypothesis of the research, the path coefficient was equal to 0.47 at the confidence level of 95 percent. Therefore, the organization's external prestige significantly affected unethical behaviors (t-value = 4.15).
 
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
The external prestige of the organization affects the future and the existence of the organization and causes the managers to exert different actions and behaviors to maintain and improve it. In other words, managers and employees work in line with the image of the organization they have created in the eyes of stakeholders and society. This may cause unethical actions and behaviors despite they are very beneficial. On the other hand, the leadership of the organization and its atmosphere can moderate these behaviors. The research results will help managers and employees to understand the importance of the organization's prestige and its leadership style. In this regard, researchers are recommended to investigate the moderating role of the organization's external prestige on the association of ethical leadership with organizational citizenship behavior, commitment, and identity.
 
Keywords: External Prestige, Unethical Pro-organizational Behavior, Ethical Leadership, Saipa Group.
 

Identifying and analyzing the competencies required by the mentor in the startup growth process

Volume 17, Spring&Summer2025, August 2025, Pages 124-156

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.91702.1663

seyedhadi talebian, kamal sakhdari, Alireza airajpour, mortaza mosakhani

Abstract Identifying and analyzing the competencies needed by mentors in the growth process of startups

Abstract
The primary objective of the present study is to identify and analyze the competencies required of mentors in the startup growth process. The research is applied in nature, based on its purpose, and employs a multiple case study method for data analysis. The level of analysis encompasses startups and businesses operating within accelerators and incubators in Khorasan Razavi province. Using homogeneous purposive sampling, 25 businesses were subjected to in-depth exploratory analysis, and in-depth interviews were conducted with 34 experts and specialists in the selected organizations, achieving theoretical saturation.
The research tool was a semi-structured interview, whose validity was ensured through internal validity based on the selection of appropriate samples and reliability through the precise guidance of the interview process and the design of well-suited questions for data collection. Using a content analysis approach and through a three-stage coding process, 96 concepts were derived from the interviews and theoretical foundations during the open coding phase. Following a detailed examination and connection of concepts, 30 themes and 6 dimensions were identified.
According to the designed startup growth process model, in the ideation and concept cultivation stage, 6 mentor competencies lead to an optimal business model with 3 key characteristics. To transform the optimal business model into a functional enterprise with competitive market entry, 7 mentor competencies act as moderating factors during the startup's launch, initial growth, and sustained growth stages.
Keywords: Mentor competencies, mentoring, startup growth process

A Model for Career Path Approach to Eliminate Career Plateauing Among the Employees of Maskan Bank

Volume 15, Spring & summer 2023, September 2023, Pages 126-161

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2023.79138.1361

Jalil Ghodrati, Mohsen Moradi, Alireza Mazidi

Abstract  
1- INTRODUCTION
The new attitude toward career management considers it a tool for human resource development. The main goal of career management is to balance the organization's needs with those of employees. Job plateauing is a crucial career management factor affecting organizational outcomes. It is a point in an employee's professional life where the possibility of vertical promotion or increasing job responsibilities seems extremely weak or unlikely. In service organizations, due to the type of work and the need to have highly motivated employees with high work spirit, it is doubly important to pay attention to job plateauing. Therefore, the current research was to explain this phenomenon among the employees of Maskan Bank.
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
The career path is an arrangement of the work-life according to employees' attitudes and motivations they have to perform their work roles. Career path allows employees to see their future direction in the organization as well as the abilities and skills needed to be prepared with enthusiasm for the new position. Accordingly, the career path is capable of reducing job plateauing. A career path requires motivation and a clear view of progress that can be created by career management. Indeed, through career path development, career management can reduce the possibility of job plateauing.
 
3- METHODOLOGY
Since this research seeks to develop a model to eliminate job plateauing with a career path approach, it is an applied study. According to the method, it is a descriptive survey. Following a career path approach in the qualitative phase, the indicators of job plateauing were identified based on reviewing the literature and conducting semi-structured interviews. Then, they were categorized using an exploratory factor analysis. After that, a Delphi questionnaire that was designed from identified indicators was provided to experts. The statistical population of the qualitative phase is comprised of Maskan Bank experts in employment and human resource management and university professors. In the quantitative phase, the staff of Maskan Bank is the statistical population. Based on Morgan's table, a sample size of 384 was selected by simple random sampling.
 
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
The results indicated three initial dimensions for the model of job plateauing. During the Delphi process, another dimension was added called social plateauing. According to experts, social plateauing means an employee prevents accepting more responsibilities due to their dependence on other people (e.g., parents) or a second job. Nowadays, to prevent an imbalance between work and personal life, employees consider both their personal and family lives and may prefer to remain in their current jobs instead of holding more job responsibilities in higher positions.
 
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Due to changes in organizational environments, job plateauing is considered one of the most critical issues related to career management. According to the results of Delphi, job plateauing is comprised of four dimensions, including structural, content, work-life, and social plateauing. Adjusting the job flatness with other factors provides a necessary context for increasing vitality, social harmony, social interaction, job and life satisfaction, social responsibility, social participation, and growth. On the one hand, considering the organizational structure of Maskan Bank, the possibility for its employees to be promoted in the hierarchy of positions is not possible or done slowly. On the other hand, its field of specialized activity (housing and construction) makes most of employees' affairs monotonous and repetitive. Therefore, to reduce the rate of job plateauing, it is suggested that employees of Maskan Bank participate in decision-making and that managers include organizational solidarity in the organization's plans to decrease job conflict.

Assessing the Organizational Transformation Based on Architecture in the Research Center of Iran's Parliament

Volume 16, Spring&Summer2024, July 2024, Pages 127-164

https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.87300.1557

Salar Moradi

Abstract  
1- INTRODUCTION
Organizational transformation based on architecture is one of the most important tools of change in organizations. This approach is emphasized in the field of information technology planning in public and private organizations. The benefits of architecture-based organizational transformation are obvious for all organizations. The more organizations face environmental changes, the more they need architecture-based organizational transformation. In other words, it is a rapid response to ever-changing and complex environments towards a common goal. Therefore, in an organization like the Parliament Research Center, organizational transformation based on architecture is a constructive approach to create transformation in the entire organizational structures of the country. Accordingly, this research aims to measure organizational transformation based on architecture within this organization.
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Architecture-based organizational transformation is defined by alignment, integration, flexibility, and agility. All these four components are based on information technology. From the point of view of information technology, this type of transformation is focused on achieving the alignment of the market and information technology, supporting the organizations' strategies. In general, the alignment of information technology is a prerequisite to supporting intelligence in society and achieving digitization. The organizations' development is accelerated through integration based on information technology, reducing the risk of projects. In addition to improving the current state of organizational transformation, this integration type can advance the organizational goals. Since every organization is constantly under pressure from external factors, it requires a certain level of flexibility. The most important reason for organizational transformation based on architecture is the necessity of responsiveness against environmental changes. Agile organizational architecture is a new idea for improving the existing transformation tools. With an agile architectural process, the transformation process gains more momentum.
 
3- METHODOLOGY
This is quantitative research. The statistical population includes all managers, deputies, and experts of the Parliament Research Center in 2023, among which 95 people were selected using quota sampling. The tool for measuring organizational architecture was a researcher-made questionnaire developed using the existing theoretical models and related studies. Two indices of CVR and CVI were employed to assess the content validity of this questionnaire. In addition, a first-order confirmatory factor analysis was utilized in Amos Graphics software to estimate the questionnaire’s construct validity. Furthermore, Cronbach's alpha coefficient was used to evaluate its reliability.
 
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
The coefficient between alignment and integration, 0.85, was the biggest correlation coefficient between the latent variables. After that, the correlation between flexibility and empowerment with a coefficient of 0.78 was dramatic. The smallest correlation was calculated 0.51 belonged to the relationship between alignment and flexibility. The statistical indicators indicated the high validity of the organizational transformation construct, and thus, this research can be used as a basis for future research. In general, research findings indicated that organizational transformation based on architecture not only is a necessity for organizations but also it should be considered as a supreme goal.
 
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Many researchers have emphasized organizational architecture as a tool for transformation in organizations. Technology-based architecture not only affects organizational strategy, but also creates alignment between technical and social systems and, consequently, will increase organizational effectiveness. The organizational architecture is efficient when it creates integration in all the technology sectors. Furthermore, flexibility is necessary to accompany the changes in the architectural process. Considering the importance of architecture-based organizational transformation for all organizations, it is suggested that the top and middle management of the organization pursue architecture-based organizational transformation projects. To do so, the corporate strategies should be determined in advance and organizational transformation should be placed above them. The excellence of organizational culture is also important as one of the main solutions for improving organizational transformation based on architecture.