Exploring the Antecedents of a Healthy Organization in the Ministry of Interior
Volume 17, Autumn 2025 and Winter 2026, December 2025
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.94327.1727
Ghader khodaveirdizadeh, Jafar Beikzad, hossein Emari, Yusuf Beighzadeh
Abstract This research aims to explore the antecedents of a healthy organization in the Ministry of Interior. This research is based on the pragmatism paradigm in terms of philosophy, an applied development in terms of objectives, and a mixed exploratory type in terms of the nature of the data. The strategy of this research is qualitative, based on thematic analysis. The study population consists of three groups: academic experts, expert consultants, and executive managers of the governorates in the East Azerbaijan, West Azerbaijan, and Ardabil provinces. In this study, purposive and snowball sampling methods were used to select the sample, and data saturation was achieved through 13 interviews. The data were analyzed using a three-phase approach of thematic analysis with MAXQDA2020 software. According to the data analysis from the interviews, the study identified a total of 43 basic themes, 12 organizing themes, and 4 overarching themes. Based on the findings, the antecedents of a healthy organization were examined from four perspectives: "organizational culture," "organizational structure," "leadership styles," and "organizational excellence." Overall, the study shows that a simultaneous and integrated focus on these dimensions can enhance the health and effectiveness of organizations.
Developing a Model for Managers’ Meritocracy in Mashhad Municipality by Adopting a qualitative approach (Thematic Analysis)
Volume 13, Autumn & Winter 2022, February 2022, Pages 185-205
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2022.70869.1128
hamidreza movahedizadeh, Serajhoddeen Mohebbi, Parvaneh Gelerd
Abstract
INTRODUCTION
The effectiveness of managers is highly dependent on different factors like competency, skills, aptitude, knowledge, and insight. these factors play a vital role in managers’ success and, subsequently, much effort and search are going on to employ those who have these required competencies. This can provide an appropriate environment for them to be effective managers. there are many benefits to the competency approach. For example, implementing it in employee development programs is one of the organization's inherent abilities.
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Many types of research have been carried out in different countries to model the factors affecting meritocracy. For example, one study refers to four key skills for managers’ meritocracy: self-management, interpersonal, technical, and administrative skills. Another research found that a manager’s competencies and qualifications should include emotional awareness, self-confidence, self-assessment, trustworthiness, maintaining order, flexibility, innovation, responsibility, seeking information, production efficiency, decision quality, and stress management. in another study, the manager’s competencies are divided into four categories: cognitive, functional, social, and meta competency. One another proposed a holistic domain model of managerial competencies that comprise six key domains: intrapersonal, interpersonal, leadership, technical/business, career, and mentoring skills.
METHODOLOGY
In this research, thematic analysis is used which is a method for determining, analyzing, and expressing patterns (or themes) within the data. here, the six-step method of clark and brown (2006) is conducted on interview contents. research participants include university professors and managers and experts of the municipality of mashhad, 21 of which were interviewed. the collected data were analyzed using nvivo software. then, based on the identified model, a questionnaire was developed and distributed among the research participants in order for conducting the friedman test and prioritizing the identified factors.
RESULTS & DISCUSSION
Previous studies have suggested that the competencies of managers include: individual, interpersonal, organizational, and insight competencies. according to these researches, indicators such as freshness and extraversion, humility, patience, challenge, age, and resistance to pressure are important for meritocracy. Based on the identified pattern composed of 122 open codes, 15 axial codes, and 4 selected codes, the current study concludes that the competencies needed by managers can be categorized into three dimensions: individual (attitudinal and behavioral), occupational (knowledge and skill), and value (organizational culture).
CONCLUSION & SUGGESTIONS
In regard to prioritizing the merits required by mashhad municipality managers, research findings showed that the behavioral axial code is the most important in individual competency, the leadership code is the most important in managerial competency, and the skill code is the most important in job competency. In order to establish a meritocracy system in the mashhad municipality, it seems necessary to pay attention to four categories (individual, managerial, job, and value). Accordingly, being open to criticism, sending accurate reports to all levels, communicating with urban elites, using human resources, and using specialist forces should be considered in a meritocracy system.
The Effect of Perceived Social Support on Emotional Labor Mediated by Psychological Hardiness
Volume 13, Spring & summer 2021, September 2021, Pages 189-208
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2021.31079.0
Soheil Sarshar, Zohreh Rafezi, elham saei, Rasoul Rostami Malkhalifeh
Abstract 1-INTRODUCTION Today, researchers are trying to understand the process of emotional labor. emotional labor has three components: emotional requirements, emotional regulation, and emotional performance. emotional requirements include the goal of integration in showing positive emotions and hiding negative emotions. emotional regulation is the effort of employees to adapt to the job's emotional-social demands, which has two strategies of surface action and deep action. surface action involves the artificiality of the emotions requested. deep action, on the other side, is trying to experience and feel the real thrill. emotional performance means the visible expression of emotional management. 2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK Emotional labor, from the perspective of action theory, includes surface action and deep action. social support is conceptualized as an individual's cognitive assessment of the support environment or workgroup. social protection theorists believe that social protection focuses on the cognitive assessments of individuals in their immediate environment and the degree of confidence in support. therefore, we can assume that social support increases a person's psychological capacity in the face of emotional needs by creating psychological hardiness. thus, perceived social support is related to the personality and cognitive variables of psychological hardiness. hardiness is a set of feedback and skills that build the courage to face stressful life situations. hardiness has a significant impact on how emotional needs are managed and interpreted. based on the above, a model was proposed including the following variables: social support as a predictor, surface and deep action as outcomes, and psychological hardiness as a mediator. 3- METHODOLOGY The current study is a correlation study that uses structural equation modeling as the analysis strategy. the statistical population of the study includes nurses of public hospitals in khorramabad. a sample size of 224 (125 females and 81 males) was selected by conducting a multi-stage random sampling method. the data gathering tool was a written questionnaire. 4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION The results of structural equation modeling indicated the direct coefficient of perceived social support on psychological hardiness (B = 0.148, p = 0.001), perceived social support on surface action (B = -0.134, p = 0.001), perceived social support on deep action (B = 0.40, p = 0.001), psychological hardiness on surface action (B = 0.137, p = 0.001), and psychological hardness on deep action (B = 0.143, p = 0.001). All the direct effects were significant and corresponding hypotheses were confirmed. The mediating role of psychological hardiness in the relationship between social support and emotional labor was evaluated through the bootstrapping method and confirmed. 5-CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS The results of the present study showed that the predictor variables explain 22 percent of the variance of deep action. the present study also confirmed the negative impact of perceived social support and psychological hardiness on superficial action. social support includes care and support, which empowers people to adapt to working conditions. considering the fact that emotional labor aims to emotionally adapt to the situation, social support can lead to improved emotional labor. people with psychological hardiness can easily manage emotionally demanding jobs. by flexing their flexibility and receptivity, they coordinate uncoordinated events and evaluate them appropriately. the flexibility of these people can also increase their work mastery by challenging the difficulty of the work. people with high stubbornness feel more empowered to control the events of their lives. therefore, they manage the requirements of job excitement in a more dominant way. finally, according to the emotion regulation model, it can be said that social support is a kind of adaptation that equips people with flexibility and acceptance of working conditions. therefore, by increasing the commitment and flexibility of people in difficult situations, managers can make them more efficient in handling job emotions.
Dentifying key factors Institutionalizing Jihadi Organizational Culture in Bank Melli Iran
Volume 18, Spring & Summer 2026, July 2026, Pages 200-232
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.95807.1764
Tohid Rahimi, Jafar Beikzad, farhhad Nejhad irani, Yahya Dadashkarimi
Abstract this study aims to dentifying key factors institutionalizing jihadi organizational culture in Bank Melli Iran. the research strategy is qualitative and based on thematic analysis. The research population consists of three groups: academic experts, professional specialists, and senior managers of Bank Melli Iran. for sampling, purposive and snowball sampling methods were applied, and data saturation was achieved after conducting 16 interviews. The data were analyzed using the three-stage approach of thematic analysis with MAXQDA2020 software. based on the analysis of interview data, a total of 78 basic themes, 18 organizing themes, and 4 overarching themes were identified. according to the findings, the antecedents of jihadi organizational culture were categorized into four main perspectives: justice-orientation, adherence to Islamic and revolutionary values, revolutionary insight, and jihadi behavior. overall, the study reveals that the formation of a jihadi organizational culture depends on institutionalizing ethical, religious, and revolutionary values, along with strengthening strategic insight and fostering committed and jihadi behaviors among employees. the results indicate that through the integration of these dimensions, it is possible to build a dynamic, efficient, and value-driven organization that is resilient to environmental challenges and takes more effective steps toward realizing the macro goals of the Islamic Revolution and serving society.
Investigating the Moderating Role of Emotional Intelligence on The Relationship Between Innovation Capabilities and Academic Leadership Effectiveness
Volume 14, Spring & summer 2022, September 2022, Pages 218-251
https://doi.org/10.22067/pmt.v14i1.87855
Hooman Setareh Aseman, Seyyed Mohsen Allameh, Mohammad Reza Nili Ahmadabadi
Abstract
1- INTRODUCTION
Today, higher education has undergone extensive changes and needs which greatly emphasize market forces. Innovation and adaptation to the changing external environment are among the challenges that universities face in the age of globalization. Therefore, the reliance of higher education institutes on traditional administrative and service processes can no longer guarantee the desired results. This is why higher education units are under intense pressure to increase possible flexibility and develop methods to better meet the needs of their customers. Considering the current expectations of society from universities, the main question is "do the emotional abilities of senior university managers (identifying, understanding, regulating, and managing the emotions of themselves and others) affect leadership effectiveness"? Therefore, the present study helps Iran's public higher education strategic planners to better understand the dimensions of emotional intelligence of their leaders and train these abilities and skills as superior leadership characteristics in management training programs. This study investigates the moderating effect of the emotional intelligence of academic leaders on the relationship between innovation capabilities and academic leadership effectiveness in 5 A-grade and public universities in Tehran city.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Researchers believe that social effectiveness skills are the determinants of leadership effectiveness. Some believe that leadership effectiveness refers to the actual performance of the team or the perception of the leader's effectiveness, while others refer to leadership effectiveness as the degree of adaptation between the leader's leadership style and environmental conditions. On the other hand, innovation capability has been defined as the skills and knowledge needed to effectively absorb, master, and improve existing technologies and create new possibilities. Emotional intelligence includes four abilities such as observation, evaluation, and accurate expression of emotions; facilitating the thoughts through access and production of thoughts; cognition of emotions and emotional knowledge and regulation of emotions that lead to intellectual development are introduced. Thus, emotional intelligence has been assumed as a key construct of social effectiveness and leadership effectiveness. Then, more emotionally intelligent leaders, when supporting their subordinates, can understand their emotional responses and help them understand and manage the challenges of change. Based on field and library studies of the researcher about the factors affecting the success of Iran's big public universities, as the heroes of the resistance to change, the role of emotional and perceptual abilities of leaders called emotional intelligence on leadership qualities and the effectiveness of academic leadership and facilitating and disseminating innovation in the higher education organization showed very colorful and influential. This caused the researcher to examine whether innovation capabilities affect the effectiveness of academic leadership. How influential is emotional intelligence in this relationship? Does the emotional intelligence of academic leaders act as a factor in moderating, reducing, or increasing the intensity of this relationship?
3- METHODOLOGY
The statistical population of this study is the 217 senior managers working in 5 public universities including the University of Tehran, Sharif University of Technology, University of Allameh Tabatabai, University of Shahid Beheshti, and the Tarbiat Modares University. The latent components of the variables in the research conceptual model were identified through in-depth semi-structured interviews with 11 scholars working in those universities. Using a 6-step thematic analysis, 50 items were discovered in the form of 10 measurable components to be distributed in form of a survey questionnaire among the 150 sample managers. The confirmatory factor analysis was performed and confirmed to evaluate the reliability of the index using Cronbach's alpha, CR, and factor loadings, and AVE and Fornell and Larker's matrix to evaluate the validity of the index. The structural equation modeling (SEM) method based on the least partial squares (PLS) technique was used to test the quantitative research hypotheses.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
Analyzing the research data indicated that the effect of innovation capabilities on leadership effectiveness was statistically significant. The direction of the effect is positive and the intensity of the relationship is 0.274, which indicates the average effect of innovation capabilities on leadership effectiveness. Testing the moderating impact of emotional intelligence in the second hypothesis using the interactive effect method in which the standard scores of the independent and moderator variables are multiplied and an interactive sentence is created, showed that emotional intelligence has a significant moderating role in the relationship between innovation capabilities and leadership effectiveness. In the second hypothesis, the intensity of the relationship was 0.078.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Recognizing the self and others' feelings and emotions, academic leaders can strengthen the innovative and creative thinking of their subordinates in academically challenging situations. Surely, applying these cognitive abilities innovates academic research and pedagogical processes and makes academic leadership effective and the dream of universities' social responsibility come true. As growing demand pressures, cultural shifts in higher education, managerial diversity, and financial constraints have forced higher education to change and adapt to new leadership practices, Policymakers in the ministry of sciences are suggested to innovate in research and pedagogical processes, encourage the academic staff to think about organizational processes and identify the current and future challenges higher education and research processes facing and to provide the creative and innovative ideas. In addition, they are suggested to apply the assessments of the leader's emotional intelligence and its benefits in changing the interpersonal behavior and managerial effectiveness in performance appraisal programs of the universities. Researchers and scholars are also advised to measure the emotional intelligence skill of innovative individuals in future research and to classify and rank the impact of these skills, as well as the extent to which emotional intelligence skills and ideation, and creativity are used among leaders with X and Y leadership styles.
Identifying the Determinant Factors of Firms’ Growth in Emerging Markets: A Meta-Synthesis Study
Volume 15, Spring & summer 2023, September 2023, Pages 221-267
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2023.83412.1462
Behzad Sadeghi, Kamal Sakhdari
Abstract
1- INTRODUCTION
Studies show that high-growth firms play a vital role in increasing the number of jobs, improving productivity, and creating new products. Accordingly, firm growth has been the focus of entrepreneurship, strategic management, and economics researchers in recent years. However, although a lot of research has been done on the factors affecting the growth of these firms in developed economies, our knowledge of emerging economies is scattered and little. Firms operating in emerging economies face unique challenges such as institutional gaps, lack of infrastructure, and political instability. Therefore, it seems that the theories developed regarding firm growth in developed economies are not suitable for explaining this phenomenon in the context of emerging markets. In addition, since studies conducted in emerging markets have dealt with firm growth through different lenses, including institutional, resource-based, and network approaches, this has led to the dispersion of existing knowledge in this field. According to this, A comprehensive framework for identifying factors affecting the growth of firms in these markets has not yet been provided. Therefore, it seems that the analysis and synthesis of existing knowledge in the field of firm growth in emerging markets will provide researchers with the possibility of a better understanding of this phenomenon.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
In general, firm growth is a multifaceted concept defined differently by scholars. Previous studies in the field of factors affecting the growth of firms have also examined this phenomenon from different aspects. A group of researchers has focused on market-oriented strategies emphasizing the importance of understanding and identifying customers' needs and preferences and competitors' activities to achieve competitive advantage. Another group of researchers, by adopting a resource-based perspective, emphasizes the role of valuable, rare, inimitable, and irreplaceable resources in gaining competitive advantage and growth. However, institutional theory is a more recent perspective to approach firm growth. This viewpoint points out that, in addition to the firm's strategy and resources, institutions determine the extent of its growth. Finally, the most recent perspective on firm growth comes from the network theory, which has been emphasized especially in the context of firms' growth in emerging markets. This theory highlights the importance of relationships and social capital in facilitating the growth of firms.
3- METHODOLOGY
This research is a fundamental study concerning purpose, and regarding the data collection method, it is a meta-synthesis study. By comparing and combining the qualitative findings of previous research, meta-synthesis can help advance theories, resolve conflicts within a field, and identify future directions for research. The current research has utilized Sandelowski and Barroso's meta-synthesis model. This approach provides a systematic review of qualitative research findings and allows the researcher to interpret existing findings through a 7-step systematic process. According to the main research question in the first step, to collect research data, keywords and phrases related to firm growth in emerging economies were identified. Then, to systematically review and find the sources, the desired keywords were searched in the title, abstract, and keywords in the three subject categories of management and business, economics, and social sciences in the scientific databases of Web of Science and Scopus. Finally, after removing unrelated articles, 104 articles related to the research question were obtained, and in this way, the qualitative findings of these articles were used for the final analysis.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
Regarding growth in emerging markets, the research findings indicated that organizational characteristics, managerial characteristics, resources, strategy, and environment are the five components of firm growth. Also, The research findings show that in the context of these economies, in addition to technical and market capabilities, firms should have organizational capabilities such as agility, organizational resilience, and political capabilities to protect themselves against environmental uncertainty. Moreover, it was determined that the firms' political capital is a multi-purpose concept, providing access to financial and physical resources in line with the firm's growth. Identifying the formal and informal market sectors in emerging economies, the findings also recommend the firms develop appropriate strategies for these sectors.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Previous studies regarding the factors affecting the growth of firms in emerging economies have addressed this phenomenon with different approaches, which has led to the dispersion of existing knowledge. This research was conducted to fill this theoretical gap and identify the factors affecting the growth of firms in emerging markets. The research results emphasize the market-political ambidexterity strategy, having complementary market and non-market strategies, and enhancing the team's professional characteristics. Also, according to these results, future research is suggested to identify the mechanisms of isolation of competitive advantage in emerging economies, identify non-market complementary strategies, investigate the effect of political capital as a multi-purpose capital on the growth of firms, and identify various strategies that firms use for the formal and informal sectors.
Investigating Relationships between Entrepreneurial Spirit, Academic Performance, and Propensity to Immigrate Among Students Using SEM (Case Study: Ferdowsi University and Mashhad Medical Sciences)
Volume 17, Spring&Summer2025, August 2025, Pages 231-269
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.90930.1638
Maryam sadat Afkhami Mostafavi, Masoud Imanian, mahnaz amirpour
Abstract Today, elite migration is one of issues in Iran. Therefore, aim of this study is to investigate relationships between entrepreneurial spirit, academic performance, and propensity to immigrate among students using a structural equation approach using a descriptive-correlational method. Online questionnaires were collected from students at Ferdowsi University and Mashhad Medical Sciences during two months (October and November 2017). Research findings showed that among dimensions of entrepreneurial spirit, achievement-seeking dimension received the highest score and risk-taking dimension received the lowest score. The results of Pearson test indicate that the higher the entrepreneurial spirit in students, the higher their propensity to immigrate. The results of the Spearman correlation coefficient test also showed that there is a positive relationship with a magnitude of 0.378 between two variables of quality of academic life and tendency to migrate, and the higher quality of academic life of students, the higher their tendency to migrate. The results of structural equation model indicated that entrepreneurial spirit has a positive effect on academic performance with a standard coefficient of 0.605 and students with a stronger entrepreneurial spirit have better academic performance. Entrepreneurial spirit also has an effect on the tendency to migrate with a coefficient of 0.527 and students with a stronger entrepreneurial spirit show a greater tendency to migrate. Academic performance also has an effect on the tendency to migrate with a coefficient of 0.111 (with a lower intensity than the previous two factors). Based on the results, it is suggested that use of entrepreneurial spirit in the form of university-industry relations and projects related to entrepreneurship of students of Ferdowsi University of Medical Sciences of Mashhad; should be such that it can play an effective role in reducing their tendency to migrate.
Identifying the Indicators and Outcomes of Exploitative Leadership in Government Organizations with FCM Approach
Volume 15, Autumn & Winter 2024, February 2024, Pages 238-272
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.84834.1491
Ali Shariat Najade, Farnaz Mehdikhani
Abstract
1- INTRODUCTION
Considering the importance of the role of government organizations in society, it should be stated that if the leaders of these organizations do not have leadership competence and competence, they can have dangerous effects on the organization with any of their behaviors, such as leadership incompetence, corruption, vandalism, immoral behavior, and criminal behavior. Therefore, it can be said that it is necessary to pay attention to the managers' leadership style, specifically exploitative leadership in these organizations. So far, most studies have investigated positive and constructive leadership styles, but less attention has been paid to the exploitative leadership style. In fact, despite a high amount of research on destructive leadership and its different styles in the country, there is little about exploitative leadership style, indicating a theoretical and practical gap. As a result, this research seeks to identify and highlight the indicators of exploitative leadership and the unfortunate outcomes of this leadership style in government organizations.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Exploitative leadership falls under the umbrella of destructive leadership because these leaders show a variety of negative behaviors. Despite research on leader self-interest, there is limited understanding of leader exploitation. Exploitative leadership is defined as a destructive leadership style in which the leader (1) exhibits selfish behavior, (2) pressures employees, and (3) undermines their skills and expertise and creates barriers to their personal growth. Previous research has shown many unfavorable effects of exploitative leadership on employees, including reduced job satisfaction and emotional commitment, increased turnover intention, burnout, workplace deviance, and perceived imbalance in social exchange.
3- METHODOLOGY
The current research is an applied study in terms of purpose, and regarding the method, it is an exploratory study. The expert team of the current research is the managers of the government organizations of Lorestan province along with the university professors, which was conducted using the purposeful sampling method and numbered 25 people. The tool for collecting information is an interview in the qualitative part and a questionnaire in the quantitative part. Qualitative data were analyzed using the opinions of 25 experts and up to the point of information saturation and theoretical adequacy. Qualitative data were analyzed with "Atlas T" software and content analysis method, and quantitative data were analyzed with the fuzzy cognitive mapping method.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
The findings of the research show that the most influential indicators of exploitative leadership are extreme ambition, hubristic personality, self-centeredness, and self-interest. Also, the reduction of motivation and innovative performance of employees, job and emotional burnout, the emergence of a paranoid atmosphere, and the spread of organizational pessimism were identified as the most significant consequences of exploitative leadership.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
The performance and actions of leaders do not always lead to the organization's success and progress. In some cases, adverse and unethical leadership styles, such as exploitative leadership, can be the cause of pushing employees and the organization toward decline. In general, exploitative leadership can have unfavorable effects on the performance of employees and, consequently, on the organization's performance. Therefore, the current research was conducted to identify indicators and consequences of exploitative leadership in government organizations.
Quantitative Analysis of Relationships among Supportive Organizational Culture, Leadership Performance, Job Satisfaction, Organizational Trust, and Job Involvement
Volume 16, Spring&Summer2024, July 2024, Pages 240-277
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.84646.1484
Usef Ramezani, Zahra Rafizadeh, Ghasem Anvari, Shaghayegh Torabi
Abstract
1- INTRODUCTION
Job satisfaction is one of the most important variables in organizational behavior, increasing employees' efficiency and individual satisfaction. Organizational culture affects the behavior of employees. Also, a supportive organizational culture may significantly affect employees' motivations, job satisfaction, and morale. Organizational culture, leadership, and employees' mental involvement are the effective factors in increasing job satisfaction, but little was investigated in previous research. Accordingly, this research aimed to analyze the associations among supportive organizational culture, leadership performance, job satisfaction, organizational trust, and job involvement.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Job satisfaction is the key to the success of any organization. Employees with higher job satisfaction perform better than those with lower job satisfaction. If employees have a suitable level of satisfaction, they are more involved in their jobs. Organizational culture is the employees' perception of their organization, representing the usual and fixed characteristics that distinguish an organization from the others. A supportive culture minimizes the pressure on employees to exert a particular behavior and encourages them to pursue their work based on goals and values. Leadership style is a permanent and continuous behavioral pattern that people use to influence others in place of work.
3- METHODOLOGY
The present research is a practical study in terms of purpose, and regarding the method, it is a descriptive-correlational study. The statistical population comprised 178 employees working for Atiehsazan Supplementary Insurance Company in Mashhad. The census method was used to study the target population. The survey tool is a questionnaire, the first part of which consists of demographic variables including gender, education, and job tenure, and the second is dedicated to the items of the scales. The validity of gathered data was evaluated by content and construct indices, and its reliability by Cronbach's alpha. Structural equation modeling was conducted in SmartPLS software to test the research hypotheses.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
The results revealed significant coefficients for organizational culture on job involvement, organizational culture on organizational trust, leadership performance on organizational trust, job involvement on job satisfaction, and organizational trust on job satisfaction. Furthermore, organizational trust mediated the effect of leadership performance on job satisfaction.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
According to the results, the more the employees perceive a supportive atmosphere, the more they are involved in their jobs, increasing mental engagement. Managers should improve the organization's performance by strengthening the organizational culture to provide employees with psychological safety and mutual trust. In this regard, it is suggested that managers pay due attention to the employees' values and motivation, having a dramatic role in their participation. In addition, it increases their level of trust, satisfaction, and involvement. Leadership styles should be based on collaboration and teamwork rather than making decisions only on top of the organization, such that the employees are attached like family members. Therefore, they develop the necessary skills to exert ethical behaviors because of increased organizational trust.
Designing a Model for Developing Public-Sector Entrepreneurship Factors
Volume 16, Autumn&Winter2025, January 2025, Pages 298-329
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.89085.1587
Bijan Rezaee, Mahdi Hosseinpour, Said Bakhshi, Mahtab Mortezaei
Abstract 1- INTRODUCTION
In the modern era, the development of information and communication technologies has influenced many aspects of human life, complicating and obscuring environmental conditions, rules of engagement, and competitive landscapes. Consequently, organizational survival and sustainability depend on innovation, creativity, and the development of new products and processes. Entrepreneurship stimulates economic growth and creates a favorable economic environment for a nation. This is why governments have prioritized the promotion of entrepreneurship. According to the 2020 Global Entrepreneurship Index report, Iran's entrepreneurship ecosystem is underdeveloped, with an overall entrepreneurship score of only 268. Among the 47 countries in the Middle East region evaluated in this report, Iran ranks 32nd. Given these circumstances, this study aims to formulate a model of factors influencing the development of public-sector entrepreneurship within the Agricultural Jihad Organization of Ilam City, with a focus on enhancing entrepreneurship policy development and achieving entrepreneurial outcomes. It is worth noting that previous research has rarely addressed the formulation of a model for entrepreneurship development within public organizations. This study seeks to identify the variables influencing public-sector entrepreneurship development, presenting them in a model that emphasizes the role of government and is tailored to the specific conditions of the province, while addressing the challenges associated with designing an entrepreneurship development model.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Given the hidden benefits of entrepreneurship and the use of entrepreneurial initiatives in government organizations, the need to identify the components of government entrepreneurship in government organizations is inevitable. There has been little research in the country on the entrepreneurial government. By reviewing the studies mentioned in the research background, entrepreneurship in the government sector has been studied from different perspectives. However, each of these studies has focused on a general view of the subject and only on examining and identifying specific and limited areas of the entrepreneurial government; in such a way that none of the studies conducted so far have presented a local model of the factors affecting the entrepreneurial government, and this indicates a research gap in the field of developing the entrepreneurial government. Now, this study, by analyzing and comparing different models and variables of government entrepreneurship, based on thematic analysis and the Delphi method, has presented a local model for the development of the entrepreneurial government in agricultural Jihad organizations.
3- METHODOLOGY
This study employs a mixed-methods approach and is applied in terms of purpose. In the qualitative phase, the research population included 11 professors and experts actively involved in entrepreneurship in Ilam province. They were selected through purposive sampling, and data were gathered using semi-structured interviews with thematic analysis, continuing until theoretical saturation was achieved. The quantitative phase's population consisted of 215 managers and postgraduate-level experts from the Agricultural Jihad Organization and affiliated institutions in Ilam province. Using Cochran's formula, a sample of 138 participants was selected through simple random sampling, and questionnaires were distributed among them. Data were collected through a researcher-developed questionnaire. For data analysis, descriptive and inferential statistics (structural equation modeling) were utilized, using SPSS23 and Amos23 software.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
The reliability results (Cronbach's alpha) for the research variables were above 0.78, and the composite reliability (CR) coefficient was also above 0.78. The normality (K-S test) of each variable showed a significance level greater than 0.05. Based on thematic analysis, the indicators were categorized into nine components, and confirmatory factor analysis results indicated that factor loadings for the items were greater than 0.50 and were significant at a 95% confidence level. Convergent validity among the research variables was confirmed based on the average variance extracted (AVE), which was satisfactory. Structural equation modeling was used to validate the relationships between the constructs. According to the model output in the standard estimation mode in Amos, the explanatory relationships of the variables for public-sector entrepreneurship development were confirmed, and the proposed model demonstrated a good fit.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
The findings from the semi-structured interviews, analyzed using thematic analysis and structural equation modeling, confirmed a model consisting of nine components: religious factors, strategic planning, entrepreneurship development policy vision, mission of entrepreneurship policy development, support and sponsorship for entrepreneurship, entrepreneurial values, short-term entrepreneurship goal-setting and planning, entrepreneurship development policy, and entrepreneurship policy-making and development. This model is valuable for policymakers, managers, and stakeholders in entrepreneurship development, especially planners in public organizations like the Agricultural Jihad Organization of Ilam. The proposed model serves as a foundational framework for other institutions, enabling organizational managers to design, implement, and evaluate entrepreneurship development models that align with the micro- and macro-level realities of their organizations and the country as a whole. Public-sector entrepreneurship and related policies represent a complex, multidimensional phenomenon influenced by numerous factors, requiring a systematic, realistic, and long-term approach for implementation at both the organizational and national levels. By addressing the components of this model, organizational capabilities and limitations can be better managed, which may pave the way toward entrepreneurship development within the Agricultural Jihad Organization.
Identification and analysis of key success factors and consequences of virtual leadership style implementation with FCM fuzzy mapping method
Volume 17, Autumn 2025 and Winter 2026, December 2025
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.90700.1633
Ali shariat Najade, hanieh hatami, razieh hasanvand
Abstract In the current era, technology and information technology has become a permanent tool in human interactions, which requires a change in leadership approach. Therefore, the current research was conducted with the aim of identifying and analyzing the key factors of success and the consequences of implementing the virtual leadership style. The current research is an exploratory research in terms of practical purpose in terms of gathering information. Also, this research is a type of mixed qualitative and quantitative research based on comparative and inductive philosophy. The statistical population of the research is organizational managers along with university professors, and they were selected with the purposeful sampling method due to their theoretical and practical familiarity with the research topic and based on the principle of theoretical saturation. The data collection tool is interview in the qualitative part and questionnaire in the quantitative part. The data collection tool is in the qualitative part of the interview, the validity and reliability of which was confirmed using content validity and theoretical validity and intra-coder and inter-coder reliability methods. Also, the tool for collecting information in the quantitative part is a questionnaire whose validity and reliability were confirmed using the content validity and reliability of the test. In this research, the content analysis and coding method was used in the qualitative part and the FCM fuzzy cognitive map method was used in the quantitative part for data analysis. The research results include the identification and analysis of key success factors and the consequences of virtual leadership style implementation. The results of this research indicate that the necessity of establishing coordination and communication between team members, electronic intelligence skills, knowledge and awareness of virtual leaders towards leading in a multicultural and multilingual society are the most important antecedents of virtual leadership style. Also, the high speed of communication, formality and de-bureaucracy were identified as the most important suffixes of virtual leadership
Investigating the Relationship between Managers’ Narcissism and Inventory Shortages with the Moderating Effect of Auditor Tenure in Companies
Volume 18, Spring & Summer 2026, July 2026, Pages 1-26
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2026.93685.1709
Saeed Namazi Baygi, Mohammad Hossein Vadeei, Ahmad Alizadeh
Abstract Abstract
Decisions made by narcissistic CEOs can have significant consequences for companies, and these effects may be influenced by the tenure of the external auditor. Accordingly, the present study aims to investigate the relationship between CEO narcissism and inventory shortages, with a focus on the moderating role of the auditor’s tenure in publicly traded companies. This research is practical in nature and analyzes real data from firms listed on the Tehran Stock Exchange. To achieve the research objectives, data from 140 companies over the period 2016 to 2023 were collected and analyzed. Multivariate regression models with panel data were employed to test the hypotheses. The findings reveal a positive and significant association between CEO narcissism and inventory shortages. Furthermore, auditor tenure was found to strengthen this relationship as a moderating factor.
In conclusion, the study suggests that companies with narcissistic CEOs and longer auditor tenures are more likely to experience inventory shortages. These results offer valuable insights for investors, creditors, and regulatory bodies in assessing corporate financial and managerial behavior.
Investigating the Affecting Factors of Teamwork Effectiveness
Volume 13, Spring & summer 2021, September 2021, Pages 209-232
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2021.68402.1034
zahra rajae, Samira Pour, hosein karjooy
Abstract 1- INTRODUCTION
In today's organizations, the various groups perform most of the tasks directly or indirectly. nowadays, managers tend to team working increasingly. essentially, team working resulted in making loyalty, responding to innovation, flexibility, and organizational efficiency. although there is some evidence that shows researching the group-working can have a positive effect on the efficiency of the team working, but there are only a few studies about the level of group or team. therefore, as teamwork and teamwork become more interestingly that has a root in the rapid changes of the organizations' conditions such as organizational restructuring, competition in the world trade, increasing the labor force diversity and the technology development, such studies are necessary. nevertheless, these studies are few and weak in iran and iranian organizations. therefore, since the management theories such as the new management and leadership theories, the quality circles, the techniques of total quality management, the participatory management techniques, the theory of technical-social systems and organization with the likert interlocking rings, the network, organic and multi-criteria structures and so on have a special focus on the team working to do the task efficiently, it is more important to do these studies in water and waste water company of south khorasan. this always was one of the most important matters, issues, and priorities in water and waste water company of south khorasan to study the effective factors in doing the efficient team working in the company for providing some approaches to remove the obstacles in this matter and making capacity in this field of research.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Perceiving the concepts of group and team is necessary to perceive the concepts of teamwork and teamwork correctly. There are many definitions for "group" that shows the various attitudes of thinkers about this social phenomenon. Kaminsky (2017) defines a group as a gathering of two or more people that have meaningful and purposeful individual contact with each other continuously. There are many models focusing on the efficiency of teamwork, among which the Gladstein (1984) model was selected for this study. This model encompasses such concepts as group tasks, group processes, group structure, group composition, available resources, and organizational structure. The aspects of evaluating the teamwork efficiency also include achieving the goals, learning and the quality of the work, the quantity of the work, participation, and motivation, and improving the work relationships.
3- METHODOLOGY
This research is a practical study in terms of purpose, and in terms of method, it is a descriptive survey. we have used the pls and version 23 of spss software to analyze the information. the statistical population of this study includes the staff of south khorasan urban water and sewerage company in 2019 and the total size of the population is equal to 200 individuals. therefore, we selected 127 individuals by morgan's table and by conducting a simple random sampling. we used a pre-made questionnaire based on previous research ranging on a 5-point likert scale.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
We used the opinions of 20 people including university management professors and experts to evaluate the questionnaire's content validity. the cronbach's alpha coefficient and composite reliability were used to evaluate reliability. to analyze gathered data, we have used pls-sem by conducting hulland's two-step procedure. according to path coefficients and p-values, the effect of available resources on the group processes and the effect of adjusting the role of the group tasks in the relationship between group processes on the group effectiveness were not confirmed, but the other hypotheses were statistically significant. according to the value of the gof index, it can be said that the model is goodly fitted to data.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
According to the research results, it was determined that the situation of the effective aspects in doing the teamwork is at an average level and only the aspect of the available resources is in a weaker situation. based on confirmed hypotheses of the research, we suggest that the group members must have complementary skills so that they can cover each other; according to the type of the work, the number of members to do the job must be enough; the manager of the group must support the collective reason and authorize the members; most of the work decisions must be taken by the group members, not by the manager; all of the group members must participate equally in the work; they must be able to discuss their problems with the group members honestly and finally the tasks and responsibilities must be divided fairly to do the work efficiently.
Utilizing a Mixed Approach to Design a Model of Managerial Competencies Based on Organizational Health
Volume 15, Spring & summer 2023, September 2023, Pages 268-300
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2023.76755.1306
Sara Javanbakht, Mohammad Mohammadi, Hamid Rezaiefar
Abstract
1- INTRODUCTION
Globally, medical sciences universities are increasingly witnessing sophisticated guests with heightened expectations, high workforce diversity, constant emergence of new technologies, and unyielding cost pressures in the wake of intense competition. Thus, the role of managers is exceedingly becoming dynamic and highly complex. These university players should grapple with rapid change and the challenges of surviving in an information-based, knowledge-intensive, and service-driven economy. Such challenges have brought about a dramatic shift in the strategic imperatives of medical sciences universities and thrown up a new set of role demands and professional challenges for senior managers and leaders in the industry. These universities, therefore, must develop leaders with competencies that correspond with and are specific to their distinct business challenges and goals to better their organizational health. This study aims to design a model of managerial competencies based on organizational health using a mixed approach. Considering the importance of health issues in organizations and the need to promote them in medical sciences universities, this research may enrich the literature on organizational health in addition to providing practical implications for the population under study.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
The origins of the meritocracy movement can be traced back to Katz's work in the 1950s. Although he did not use the terms competence or competence, he introduced three categories of technical, human, and administrative skills, which provided a framework for distinguishing the performance of effective managers according to skills, which had a significant contribution to the foundation of the competence approach. After that, Selznick and his successor, McClelland, used the term competence to indicate a substantial factor that affects individual learning. In 1991, Woodruff proposed competence in the form of behavioral dimensions and a combination of motivation, trait, skill, self-concept, and social role. By combining their knowledge, skills, and abilities, competent managers can perform their duties and responsibilities in a way compatible with the organization's strategic goals. Organizational health, as the primary indicator of organizational effectiveness, refers to the organization's ability to continue its life so that it confronts the external destructive forces and directs them toward its main goals and objectives. According to Parsons' (1961) organizational genealogy, which is derived from his general theory of social systems, any organization must have four characteristics for its survival and continuous growth: 1) adaption: acquiring sufficient resources and compatibility with its environment; 2) goal achievement: setting goals and implementing them; 3) Unity: maintaining the integrity and internal coherence of the organization; 4) Invisibility: creating and maintaining the specific values of the organization.
3- METHODOLOGY
The research is "applied" in terms of its purpose, which was carried out within the framework of the pragmatism paradigm and the mixed-exploratory (qualitative-quantitative) approach. Based on this, first, the foundation's qualitative data research method was used, and managerial competencies were identified based on the participants' point of view. Accordingly, the sampling method was purposeful and judgmental. Based on this, 22 faculty members and administrators of medical sciences universities with managerial experience were selected. The interviewees included nine academic faculty members and nine executive directors of the university. We used semi-structured interviews to study participants and a three-stage process with open, central, and selective coding to analyze the data. In the quantitative phase, we conducted a structural equation modeling in SmartPLS v.3 to validate the proposed model. The data collection tool in the quantitative phase was a questionnaire designed based on qualitative results. The quantitative sample included 800 presidents, vice presidents, and senior managers in medical sciences universities selected by stratified random sampling.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
The results indicated that the competencies of organizational health management include cognitive, social, functional, strategic, and ethical. Causal factors affecting organizational health management competencies include organizational and individual. Influential background factors include organizational values, cooperative culture, inter-individual trust, honesty and transparency in the workplace, and institutional requirements of the external environment. Intervening factors include the characteristics of employees such as job satisfaction, loyalty, organizational commitment, adherence, and belongingness. Individual strengthening strategies include empowering human resources, cultivating employees' professional ethics, and managing employees' attitudes and behaviors. Organizational strategies include reward systems and culture and change management.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Since few studies exist on competencies of organizational health management, the current research helps strengthen the existing knowledge in the field. This issue reveals the contribution of the present research by developing a competency model. It can be an important starting point for further studies on promoting organizational health through managers' competencies.
Modeling Organizational Culture in the Context of Digital Transformation in Public Organizations
Volume 17, Spring&Summer2025, August 2025, Pages 270-309
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.91947.1674
payam karami, Masoud bastami, mansour irandoost
Abstract The primary problem addressed by this research is the identification of cultural challenges faced by organizations, particularly public organizations, during digital transformation, and the development of a model for fostering an organizational culture conducive to these changes. Accordingly, the purpose of this study is to model organizational culture in the context of digital transformation in public organizations. A mixed-methods approach (qualitative-quantitative) is employed, utilizing meta-synthesis in the qualitative phase and Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM) in the quantitative phase. For this, 18 selected qualitative studies on organizational culture and digital transformation, published in the last decade, were systematically reviewed and analyzed. Following a three-stage screening process, 284 initial codes were extracted, leading to the identification of 16 key themes. Subsequently, leveraging the ISM method and the input of 10 experts, these 16 factors were structured into a six-level model. The modeling results indicate that 'Transformational Leadership' resides at the highest level (Level 1), while 'Transformation Management,' 'Digital Needs,' 'Organizational Professional Needs,' and 'Technology Advancement' are at the lowest level (Level 6). Other factors include 'Innovation Culture,' 'Risk-Taking Culture (Type 1),' and 'Agility Culture' (Level 2); 'Alignment and Coordination Culture,' 'Customer Orientation Culture,' and 'Participation and Collaboration Culture' (Level 3); 'Digital Empowerment' and 'Technology Acceptance' (Level 4); and 'Change Management,' 'Support for Change Process,' and 'Risk-Taking Culture (Type 2)' (Level 5). MICMAC analysis further revealed that 'Digital Empowerment' and 'Technology Acceptance' play key linking roles within this model. The findings of this research, offering a structured framework, underscore the importance of a comprehensive and integrated approach to cultivating a digital organizational culture in public organizations. This model assists their managers and decision-makers in designing and implementing more effective strategies to facilitate the digital transformation process through a deeper understanding of the influential factors and their interrelationships.
Brand Engagement in Hotel Industry: The Role of Corporate Social Responsibility, Brand Trust, and Brand Identification
Volume 15, Autumn & Winter 2024, February 2024, Pages 273-301
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.82973.1447
Jamshid Salar, Ramzan Gholami Avati
Abstract 1- INTRODUCTION
Today, brand engagement is considered one of the most influential marketing strategies. Brand engagement creates a sustainable competitive advantage for companies and increases their performance. Therefore, companies seek appropriate strategies to improve customer engagement with their brands. This research aimed to investigate the effect of corporate social responsibility on brand engagement regarding the mediating role of brand trust and brand identification in the hotel industry.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Brand engagement is considered a crucial strategy in marketing literature. Various research has been done on brand engagement, but little has been done about the effects of corporate social responsibility, brand trust, and brand identification on brand engagement. Also, little research has investigated the role of brand trust and identification in the relationship between corporate social responsibility and brand engagement. Previous research has examined the direct relationship between corporate social responsibility and brand engagement and has rarely examined mediating variables in the relationship between these two variables. Therefore, this research seeks to investigate the effect of social responsibility on brand engagement with the mediating role of brand trust and identification in hotels in Ramsar, one of the most vital Iranian tourism destinations. This research tries to answer this research gap and provide a comprehensive model in this field.
3- METHODOLOGY
This study is applied cross-sectional research concerning the purpose and a descriptive survey regarding the data collection method. The population of this research includes the customers of Ramsar hotels, 300 of whom were selected as the statistical sample. The questionnaire's content, convergence, and divergence validity were confirmed. Also, its reliability was confirmed using Cronbach's alpha coefficient and composite reliability. In the descriptive part, SPSS 27 statistical software was exploited, and in the inferential part, structural equation modeling was conducted in SmartPLS 4 software to test the research hypotheses.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
According to the research findings, corporate social responsibility has a positive effect on brand engagement, brand trust, and brand identification. Corporate social responsibility creates an emotional connection between the company and consumers. As a result, consumers feel like they are part of the company. Companies should have social responsibility strategies to build trust among consumers. If the organization participates in social responsibility activities, its identity and high values will be shown to customers. Brand trust positively affects brand engagement and mediates the relationship between corporate social responsibility and brand engagement. The company's reliability makes the customers provide better information and have more relationships with the company. Additionally, brand identification positively affects brand engagement and mediates the relationship between corporate social responsibility and brand engagement. Companies should differentiate their products and services from their competitors so that customers will identify with the organization's brand.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Companies should strengthen social responsibility, brand trust, and brand identification to increase customer engagement with their brand. As a result, it is suggested that hotels observe their organizational social responsibility, give importance to environmental issues in their activities, support cultural and sports events, provide more job opportunities to people, put customers as their priority, fulfill their promises, produce high-quality products, take care of their customers and establish an emotional relationship with customers so that they identify themselves with the hotel. Also, hotels should perform their activities so that customers feel the hotel has the same identity as their identity.
Presenting a Model for Evaluating Entrepreneurial Opportunities in Lorestan Non-Governmental Organizations
Volume 16, Spring&Summer2024, July 2024, Pages 278-328
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.87752.1566
Hosain Moghadam Kia, Heydar Amiran, Abdollah Kolobandi, Mohamadreza Kabaranzadghadim
Abstract
1- INTRODUCTION
Today, entrepreneurial opportunities are recognized to be necessary for economic and social development. Due to their unique nature based on public support and non-profit objectives, non-governmental organizations (NGOs) require a specific approach to identifying and evaluating these opportunities. The current study aims to provide a localized model for evaluating entrepreneurial opportunities within NGOs in Lorestan Province. The proposed model is designed to assist NGOs in better identifying existing opportunities and effectively utilizing them.
2- METHODOLOGY
This is qualitative research based on Strauss and Corbin’s approach to grounded theory. To gain a deeper understanding of how entrepreneurial opportunities are identified and evaluated in NGOs, in-depth and semi-structured interviews were conducted with 17 persons (including university professors, successful entrepreneurs, and NGO managers) who were experts in entrepreneurship. The collected data was analyzed during the open, axial, and selective coding, the results of which led to 166 meaningful propositions, 35 sub-categories, 12 main categories, and one core category.
3- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
The research findings indicate that evaluating entrepreneurial opportunities in NGOs requires considering a set of factors categorized within the study's paradigmatic model. The final model consists of six key elements: causal conditions, intervening conditions, contextual conditions, the central phenomenon, strategies, and consequences. These elements interact to provide a comprehensive framework for evaluating entrepreneurial opportunities.
Causal Conditions: Factors that directly influence the formation of entrepreneurial opportunities. These include social needs, technological changes, and competitive environments, all of which can lead to the emergence of new opportunities.
Intervening Conditions: Factors that can facilitate or hinder the process of opportunity evaluation, such as financial resources, entrepreneurial skills, and communication networks.
Contextual Conditions: Factors that provide the background for the emergence and realization of entrepreneurial opportunities, including the culture of entrepreneurship, government support, and the level of organizational readiness.
Central Phenomenon: The process of opportunity evaluation, including the identification, analysis, and selection of suitable opportunities. This process should consider all the above factors to increase the likelihood of success.
Strategies: Actions that NGOs take to exploit identified opportunities, including strategic planning, resource mobilization, and the creation of supportive networks.
Consequences: The outcomes of successfully implementing strategies, may include increased employment, improved economic status of NGOs, and enhanced living standards of the target community.
4- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
The model presented in this study offers a comprehensive and localized framework for evaluating entrepreneurial opportunities in NGOs. By considering all aspects of the entrepreneurial process, this model can help NGOs optimize their utilization of opportunities, thereby increasing their sustainability and effectiveness. Notably, the model demonstrates that success in evaluating and exploiting entrepreneurial opportunities not only contributes to the growth and development of organizations but also leads to overall social and economic improvement in the community. Other applications of this model include providing a suitable basis for sharing experiences and best practices in entrepreneurship. The model can serve as a benchmark for other provinces and countries seeking to develop entrepreneurship within NGOs. Additionally, the proposed model can aid policymakers in designing supportive programs that maximize the impact on promoting entrepreneurship within NGOs. Based on the findings, this research can serve as a foundation for future studies in the field of entrepreneurship in NGOs and offer solutions for improving the process of evaluating entrepreneurial opportunities.
Supply Chain Management with Lean and Agile Approaches Applying: System Dynamics
Volume 16, Autumn&Winter2025, January 2025, Pages 330-361
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.89099.1588
Najmeh Faregh, Seyed Mahmood Zanjirchi, Ali Morovati sharifabadi, Habib Zare
Abstract
1- INTRODUCTION
Due to the contradictions of lean and agile approaches and meanwhile, their synergy, choosing, combining, and implementing these approaches with specific goals, strategies, and limitations is a key challenge for supply chain managers. The current research aimed to develop a dynamic system for implementing lean and agile approaches in the supply chain.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Supply chain management includes the planning and management of all activities involved in the supply chain and is considered a vital factor in the competitiveness of organizations. Lean and agile approaches are among the popular approaches in supply chain management. Lean philosophy seeks to eliminate waste and reduce costs based on more output with fewer resources according to customers' needs. Governing lean thinking and principles in the value stream is called lean supply chain management. Quick response to changes in demand, in terms of volume and variety, is called agility. The concept of this approach refers to choosing the right strategy in conditions of uncertainty and providing products and services to customers at the right time and place. Empowering new competencies to respond quickly and effectively to the market is called agile supply chain management. These two approaches have different drivers, prerequisites, and strategies, and each one pursues a specific goal.
3- METHODOLOGY
The present study is in the category of qualitative-quantitative research. Based on the stages of research in the conceptual development stage, the model is placed in the category of qualitative research. At this stage, by content analysis of the research background, factors affecting the selection of agile and lean approaches have been identified. This stage includes four main steps: problem definition, data collection, analysis, and presentation of the final model. In the quantitative stage, using the system dynamics method, using the factors obtained from the first stage and lean and agile strategies, a model has been presented to evaluate the performance and choose the appropriate strategies in different conditions. Causal models and state flow have been drawn and model evaluation tests, structure evaluation, and sensitivity analysis have been done to confirm the model validity. Finally, different scenarios have been simulated and analyzed in this model. The information required for modeling and simulating the model has been collected from the Yazd Rubber Industries Complex.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
In the qualitative stage and after content analysis by reviewing articles and zigzag coding, 106 codes from 31 studies were identified as open codes. In this study, it was done. By repeatedly reviewing the identified primary codes and comparing them, the codes with common content and concepts were classified under one concept. In this way, 40 subgroups were extracted. Finally, these codes were classified into 17 groups and 4 general levels of environmental, organization-related, product-related, and functional factors. After extracting the influencing factors on the selection of lean and agile approaches, the flow model has been presented and evaluated in Vansim software. After obtaining the valid model, by changing different variables and scenario analysis, approaches have been analyzed in three different scenarios. A comparison of selected scenarios and policies for each condition shows that, as a strategic strategy, eliminating waste is a priority in all scenarios.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
The current research has theoretical and practical implications. This research is a response to the need for a systematic and comprehensive framework of vital factors in choosing appropriate agile and lean approaches. In this article, the knowledge available in the literature about the agile and lean approach in the supply chain is organized to develop a model for choosing appropriate approaches. On the other hand, organizations do not need fixed degrees of leanness or agility in different situations. The presented dynamic model can examine specific strategies of lean and agile approaches in different conditions and finally provide certain degrees of lean and agility. In the situation that in previous studies, the combination of these two approaches is usually discussed and less attention is paid to the effect of conditions on the level of leanness and agility. Although this study tried to present a dynamic model for choosing lean and agile strategies with a comprehensive look at all conditions, due to the existence of other approaches such as resilient and green, future studies may examine other effective factors and strategies to present a more comprehensive model.
Modeling Strategic Human Resource Management Based on Digital Transformation in the Mostazafan Foundation of the Islamic Revolution
Volume 17, Autumn 2025 and Winter 2026, December 2025
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.94246.1722
Masoud taheri, Gholamreza memarzadeh Tehran,, Nazanin pilehvari,
Abstract The present study was conducted with the aim of modeling strategic human resource management based on digital transformation in the Foundation of the Oppressed of the Islamic Revolution. The main research problem was the absence of an integrated model for aligning digital technologies with strategic human resource management processes in public institutions of the country. This study was developmental–applied in nature and employed a sequential exploratory mixed-methods design. In the qualitative phase, data were collected through semi-structured interviews with 12 academic and executive experts and analyzed using thematic analysis. The findings identified six key dimensions of digital strategic human resource management, including digital leadership, technical infrastructure, managerial infrastructure, employees’ digital competencies, organizational agility, and digital culture. In the quantitative phase, the relationships among these dimensions were analyzed using the Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM) method. The results indicated that digital leadership, technical infrastructure, and managerial infrastructure act as driving forces and form the foundation for the development of other components. Subsequently, these dimensions, through strengthening digital competencies and organizational agility, lead to the establishment of an integrated system for digital recruitment, development, retention, and utilization of human resources. Implementing this system enhances productivity, innovation, and both financial and non-financial performance of public organizations. The main outcome of the study is the presentation of a localized and practical model for implementing digital strategic human resource management tailored to Iran’s institutional structure, which can serve as a guideline for policymaking and implementing digital transformation in public institutions.
Developing a Model for Organizational Identity Using Grounded Theory in Iran Tractor Manufacturing Industrial Group
Volume 13, Spring & summer 2021, September 2021, Pages 233-258
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2021.30001.0
Vahid Fattahi Sarand, Ali Shaemi Barzoki, Hadi Teimouri
Abstract 1- INTRODUCTION
Organizational identity refers to the common beliefs of an organization's members. despite plenty of research on organizational identity, there is little knowledge about its affecting factors and how it is formed. in line with shaping organizational identity, some researchers emphasize internal and external factors such as organizational communications, top management activities, and human resource management. organizational identity is one of the most important factors that affect organizational performance and productivity. research shows that there exists a theoretical gap in developing systematic models for organizational identity, particularly in iranian organizations. accordingly, this study attempts to provide a comprehensive model of organizational identity in iran tractor manufacturing company.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Organizational identity involves a strong emotional attachment to the organization, which is referred to as the perception of common characteristics. according to social identity theory, the psychological relationship between employees and an organization is known as organizational identity. the power of organizational identity reflects the degree to which the employees perceive an organization as particularity and unique. the organizational identity has the ability to predict many important organizational attitudes and behaviors. it has been considered as a concept that forms the common understanding of an organization’s members of its central characteristics and it shapes a kind of shared thinking among employees.
3- METHODOLOGY
This research is a developmental and applied study in terms of purpose, and in regard to the method, it is a descriptive survey. and in terms of the research design, it is a mixed study. in the qualitative phase, grounded theory is used to create a conceptual model of organizational identity. in this regard, a three-step process of open, axial, and selective coding was performed by nvivo10 software. in the quantitative phase, confirmatory factor analysis was used to confirm qualitative findings.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
The process model developed in this research, as a native model of organizational identity, attempts to consider the issue of organizational identity from a multidimensional viewpoint. this model is capable of directing the employees' intentions and behaviors in line with the organizational goals. the results of this study made causal conclusions on the components of internal identity, employees’ empowerment, and job enrichment. leadership style is also proposed as a context for shaping organizational identity. in addition, managerial factors and financial requirements were determined to be the intervening factors. additionally, perceived organizational support and socialization were considered as effective strategies of organizational identity. finally, the consequences of organizational identity were found to have positive effects on customer performance and satisfaction.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
In order to enhance the causal conditions through internal identity, managers are advised to strengthen the trust among employees with their honest behaviors to make employees more compatible with the organization, which leads to strengthening the employees' internal identity. furthermore, to create a suitable context, it is suggested that managers improve moral and transformational leadership characteristics to increase the sense of solidarity among employees and managers. in order to create a positive role for interveners, it is suggested that managers adopt a management style based on ethical traits and cooperation with employees and show positive managerial competencies. additionally, managers are also advised to support employees in three ways as emotional, managerial, and health support. besides, it is emphasized that according to the consequences of managers' organizational identity, different roles and tasks may be assigned to employees. in the individual dimension, managers should strengthen job satisfaction, psychological security, job performance, job motivation, and organizational citizenship behavior. moreover, in the organizational dimension, it is recommended to take some defective actions to improve organizational decision-making, promote organizational commitment, productivity, and enhance the organizational image.
Developing a Leadership Model for Iranian Government Organizations
Volume 15, Autumn & Winter 2024, February 2024, Pages 302-339
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.83151.1463
Hosain Ali Najafi, Naser Poursadegh, Hamed Rahmani
Abstract
1- INTRODUCTION
Leadership is one of the most vital roles and duties of a manager. The inadequacies caused by the increase in the size of the government and the expenses of the government sector, more than ever, reveal the importance of changing government management and paying attention to the role of leaders. In this article, the authors have concluded that according to the multiple characteristics of government organizations in the present era, among the theories, models, and new concepts of leadership, attention to characteristics of the leader, follower, and context can be an efficient approach for leadership in government organizations. On this basis, considering human knowledge management with an Islamic and Quranic perspective, a new model has been designed to fill the gap in the literature.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Avolio (2012) believes that leadership comes to the fore when a leader interacts with followers in a specific context, and all work together to achieve a common goal or a set vision. Many researchers have emphasized the need to pay attention to the mutual interactions of the three dimensions of leader, follower, and context. Leadership research has gone through different paths. Leadership in Islamic culture is a blessing given by God to humanity. Talib Hasham (1991) considers leadership in the organization to be aligned with Sharia. The life-giving school of Islam is a comprehensive and perfect religion with rules and regulations for all aspects of human individual and social life. Leadership in Islamic culture is a blessing that God has made available to humanity; for that, He puts a blessing on man's neck. Therefore, in Islamic culture, man is a creature created by God and covers all his needs and shortcomings in his life. The most critical need is how to use facilities and tools i.e. leadership and management. In terms of management, it is logical and necessary for societies to have a forward-looking view of their growth and survival and plan accordingly. Leadership can pave the way for motivating everyone's determination toward the realization of the desired future, decision-making, and capacity-building for the continued life of the organization. Therefore, the present research has designed a new image of leadership by referring to Islamic texts and considering the aspects of the leader, follower, and context to provide a practical solution for the leaders and managers of the organization.
3- METHODOLOGY
This research was done in a mixed method. For extracting the dimensions and designing the model, the meta-synthesis method and interview with thematic experts have been used, and the structural equation modeling method has been used to test the model. In the qualitative part, the concepts related to leadership in the three areas of leader, follower, and context from theoretical literature, previous research, and native and Islamic studies were summarized and categorized in three stages and led to the identification of 320 basic themes and 20 secondary themes. These 20 themes were finally classified into three main categories: leader, follower, and context. Before meta-synthesis, the advantage of the qualitative method of content analysis was used to extract themes from native and Islamic studies. Based on a sample of 300 experts from defense, cultural, social, and distribution organizations, the quantitative part examined the research hypotheses. The findings of the quantitative section showed that the leader dimension and the follower dimension have a beta coefficient of 0.096 and 0.094, respectively, and the background dimension has a beta coefficient of 0.082.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
Leadership is one of the topics that can create the power of clear foresight to achieve goals in both leaders and followers. The findings of the present research show the dimensions of leadership in the three dimensions of the leader with the components of projection and foresight, encouraging and empowering, cleaning and organizing, competence, servanthood and good deeds, the dimension of the follower with the components of self-leadership and multi-dimensionality, empowerment and development, responsibility and resilience, moderation and moderation, jihadi activity and moral virtues and the context dimension with the components of social, political, cultural, economic, legal and legal contexts, security, national and international and technology have been identified and explained. The results of the quantitative section indicate that the combined attention to all three dimensions of leader, follower, and context has been able to explain 82% of the significant impact of leadership. Also, the influence of the leader dimension is stronger than the other two dimensions. The leader dimension alone can predict 93% of the meaningful impact of leadership. At the same time, the correlation of the leadership dimension with the dimensions of leader and followers is stronger than the correlation of the leader and context.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
The results of the present study based on the significant impact of all three dimensions of leader, follower, and context in the leadership of Iranian government organizations were consistent with several other studies that emphasized the identified dimensions in different areas of leadership. Also, by simultaneously considering all three structures of leader, follower, and context, it is possible to solve the complexities and dynamics of the environment. In future research, researchers can investigate the mediation role in the relationship between leader, follower, and context and the mutual correlation between these dimensions and its impact on the leadership of Iran's government organizations.
Analyzing the Concept of Fearless Organization in Hospitals under the Social Security Organization Using Rodgers' Evolutionary Approach
Volume 16, Spring&Summer2024, July 2024, Pages 329-372
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.87329.1558
Fatemeh Sadat Vahabzadeh Moghadam, Ahmad Vedadi, KaramEllah Daneshfard
Abstract
1- INTRODUCTION
The current research aims to clarify the concept of fearless organization in Iran's health and treatment sector (specifically, the hospitals of the social security organization) and further identify the characteristics, antecedents, and consequences of creating a fearless organization in the target population. Therefore, the main objective of this research is to explain the concept of fearless organization using the Rodgers analysis method.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Fearless organization is one of the new types of positive organizations, which originates from positive psychology. Positive psychology is the root and foundation of positive organizational behavior. In general, a "fearless organization" is an organization that is considered a secure base from the point of view of its employees and members. A secure base refers to the perceived security of the organization's members, which makes it easier to face discoveries and trust supervisors to solve problems. In other words, it creates psychological security so that employees can be sure of not being belittled, laughed at, or punished due to asking a question, creating an idea, exerting a concern, or making a mistake.
3- METHODOLOGY
The current research used the evolutionary approach of Rodgers' (2000) concept analysis to develop the "safe organization" notion. The basis of this research is the original work of Edmondson (2019) entitled "The fearless organization: Creating psychological security in the workplace for learning, innovation and growth." Based on the evolutionary approach of Rodgers for analyzing raw data available in the literature, some Iranian and foreign reliable, scientific databases were searched. In the preliminary search, the keywords "fearless organization, secure base, secure-based leadership, and psychological security" were used separately and, then combined. The main criteria for entering the final analysis were the texts published in English and Persian in the last forty years (i.e., from 1983 to 2023) in the management and organization fields. Also, studying the primary texts, some secondary keywords were extracted, and a list of 180 articles and books was accordingly prepared, which was reduced to 125 items based on the inclusion criteria and removing duplicate items. Finally, 77 articles, 22 books, and 9 theses containing the main keywords in their title and/or body were selected. These sources were carefully studied in depth and the data related to the concept of fearless organization and its antecedents and consequences were summarized and coded.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
The drivers of a fearless organization are found to be the following: learning from mistakes, encouraging learning, reducing shortcuts in the organization, sharing knowledge, overcoming geographical dispersion, and useful utilizing the conflicts, gaining value from the differences, implementing the results of scientific research, avoiding silence and promoting the employee voice, not too much trusting the authorities in the organization , laying the groundwork for fearless orientation, inviting employees to participate in affairs, effective response, encouraging subordinates to try, humility before subordinates, active investigation of affairs, designing and implementing coherent structures to extract ideas and concerns of employees, effective response to the risks that employees take, following examples from other successful organizations, creating a culture to create a safe organization, maintaining balance in creating psychological security, listening to the voice of silence in the organization, cultivating self-esteem in the organization, enriching the work-family bond, psychological growth at work, fostering a sense of vitality and desire to learn in the organization, and accepting the individual as legitimate and justified. The most important reasons for creating a fearless organization are as follows: the presence of fear in the organization, believing that psychological security necessarily means being good all the time, acknowledging that psychological security is a personality factor, lowering performance standards, the prevalence of reckless disclosure, failure to support innovation, failure to foster work commitment, lack of cooperative atmosphere, lack of meaningful activities, concealment of knowledge, organizational pessimism, lack of work regulation, lack of efficient response, sadness from failures, lack of emphasis on goals, and Lack of planning processes.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
In line with the concept of the fearless organization, the organization becomes a secure base. A secure base is a person, place, goal, or object that creates a sense of protection and comfort, and provides energy and inspiration to explore, take risks, and seek change. This concept originates from the "attachment theory" introduced by John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth (1988). The most important component of the fearless organization is creating psychological security. Future researchers are advised to investigate this concept and present a conceptual model specific to different organizations (including government, private, production, service, etc.) to take a step towards improving their efficiency and productivity besides helping to enrich this concept as much as possible.
Keywords: Fearless Organization, Psychological Security, Social Security Hospitals, Rodgers' Evolutionary Approach.
Exploring the Dimensions and Components of Business School Leadership Adopting an Entrepreneurial Development Approach
Volume 16, Autumn&Winter2025, January 2025, Pages 362-415
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2024.89363.1596
Maryam Chezgi, Nazia Nasery, Mohsen Moradi, Ahmad Akbari
Abstract
1- INTRODUCTION
Leadership is the cornerstone of organizational success, influencing internal operations in line with the ability to achieve strategic goals in a dynamic and competitive environment. In entrepreneurship schools, leadership is key to fostering creativity, innovation, and entrepreneurial thinking among students. This study investigates the dimensions and components of leadership in entrepreneurial schools, emphasizing its significance in promoting entrepreneurial development through strategic and adaptive approaches.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
This research is anchored in leadership theories that include transformative, participatory, and strategic paradigms. Transformative leadership emphasizes inspiring and empowering team members, fostering innovation, and achieving long-term organizational goals. Participatory leadership focuses on collaborative decision-making, ensuring the active engagement of all stakeholders. Strategic leadership, on the other hand, integrates vision and planning to ensure alignment with long-term objectives. These frameworks are synthesized to create a conceptual model tailored to entrepreneurial schools, aligning leadership styles with the unique demands of entrepreneurship education and development.
3- METHODOLOGY
The study employs a qualitative meta-synthesis methodology, systematically analyzing literature from 2010 to 2023. Using predefined criteria, 53 articles were selected from a pool of 62 based on relevance, data richness, and academic credibility. The meta-synthesis process followed the seven-stage model proposed by Sandelowski and Barroso, including systematic review, data extraction, and thematic coding. Validity and reliability were confirmed through triangulation, expert reviews, and iterative analysis, ensuring a robust synthesis of findings.
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
The findings reveal critical dimensions of leadership that contribute to the success of entrepreneurial schools:
Entrepreneurial Education: This includes innovative teaching methods, financial literacy training, and practical entrepreneurial activities integrating technology and fostering critical thinking. Examples include tailored curricula, online learning platforms, and interactive workshops to develop entrepreneurial skills.
Technological Entrepreneurship: Leveraging technology in education promotes innovative practices, such as integrating advanced tools for collaborative learning and entrepreneurship development. This approach aligns with global trends in technology-driven education.
Empowerment Strategies: The study identifies leadership approaches that empower students and teachers, focusing on capacity building, mentorship programs, and creating an enabling environment for innovation. Key strategies include fostering self-efficacy and enhancing collaborative skills.
Organizational Excellence: Leadership styles that prioritize organizational alignment and continuous improvement were shown to have significant impacts on institutional success. Participatory and transformative leadership models emerged as particularly effective in achieving organizational goals in entrepreneurial schools.
The analysis demonstrates that these leadership dimensions collectively enhance educational outcomes and prepare students to navigate complex entrepreneurial landscapes.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
The study concludes that entrepreneurial leadership is indispensable for fostering students' innovation, adaptability, and market readiness. To maximize the impact of entrepreneurial schools, leadership strategies must integrate transformative and participatory approaches with a focus on continuous development and adaptability. Suggestions include:
Curriculum Development. To design educational programs emphasizing entrepreneurial skills, financial literacy, and real-world problem-solving.
Policy Reforms. To advocate for policies that support leadership training in schools to bridge the gap between education and entrepreneurial ecosystems.
Training Programs. To implement leadership development initiatives for educators and administrators to align their practices with entrepreneurial objectives.
Technology Integration: Leverage technology to enhance learning experiences and promote innovative teaching methods.
This research underscores the transformative potential of leadership in entrepreneurial schools, offering a roadmap for fostering creativity, resilience, and strategic thinking in educational institutions.
Design and Validation of a Model of Professional Competencies for Auditors Based on Digital Transformation
Volume 17, Autumn 2025 and Winter 2026, December 2025
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.94524.1733
Majid Mohammadi, Masoud Taherinia,, Azar Moslemi, Ali Lalbar
Abstract With the expansion of emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence, big data, and blockchain, the traditional competencies of auditors are no longer sufficient to meet professional requirements in the digital era, creating an urgent need for a comprehensive model of professional competencies grounded in digital transformation. Accordingly, this study was conducted with the aim of designing and validating a model of professional competencies for auditors based on digital transformation within the Iranian Association of Certified Public Accountants. Methodologically, this research is non-experimental (descriptive) and employs a cross-sectional survey approach. In the qualitative phase, participants included auditing professors and senior managers from the Association of Certified Public Accountants, selected through purposive sampling, with theoretical saturation achieved after 15 interviews. In the quantitative phase, the statistical population consisted of managers and experts within the same association, and a sample of 140 participants was estimated using Cohen’s power analysis. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews and questionnaires. Qualitative data were analyzed using thematic analysis with MAXQDA software, while quantitative data were analyzed using the partial least squares (PLS) method via SmartPLS software. Findings revealed that the ability to manage risk and internal controls through digital tools, professional and technical knowledge in the digital era, and leadership and management of digital auditing teams significantly influence the capacity to utilize intelligent auditing technologies and implement digital transformation within auditing strategies. These components, by enhancing continuous learning and knowledge updating in the digital transformation era, as well as data-driven analytical and critical thinking skills, lead to creativity and innovation in digital auditing. Ultimately, through digital communication and interpersonal skills, professional ethics and accountability in the digital environment, and decision-making and professional judgment based on artificial intelligence, the comprehensive framework of auditors’ professional competencies in the digital era is actualized.
Introduction:
Auditing is one of the vital jobs in financial management that plays a very important role in ensuring the transparency and accuracy of financial information of companies and organizations (Azadbakht et al., 2025). The auditing profession has been influenced by digital transformation for over a decad and has been redefined in the form of “digital auditing” (Ghasemi et al., 2024). In fact, the rapid advancement of digitalization has transformed the accounting profession. Following this, audit firms and auditors have also potentially been affected by the advancement of digital technology, especially big data, artificial intelligence and blockchain, and require new professional competencies and capabilities (Hamzeh and Ramsheh, 2023). In the era of digital transformation, auditors are expected to have special capabilities & competencies. Proficiency in digital auditing address key challenges, including fraud, the expectation gap, auditor independence, and audit quality (Vitali & Giliyani, 2024). A critical concern in modern auditing amid digital transformation is to ensure the auditor's capabilities, skills, knowledge, and expertise, which has been raised as audit competencies (Sudrajat et al., 2024). Since the accuracy of audit results hinges on auditors' professional competencies, enhancing these competencies has become a priority. In the current era, when digital technologies are recreating specialized jobs at an increasing pace, the auditing profession has not been left out of this transformation. In such a context, identifying and developing professional competencies commensurate with this transformation has become a strategic necessity for the sustainability and effectiveness of auditors. The main concern in this study is to what extent the Iranian certified public accountants' community has redefined its competencies to respond to the demands of the digital age and what model can be a guide in this direction. This issue is also important from a negative perspective because the lack of a localized and systematic model for auditors' digital competencies may lead to a knowledge gap, reduced public trust, inability to adapt to new technologies, and ultimately the decline of auditors' professional status in the face of international institutions and competitive environments. In the absence of such a model, ineffective training programs and human resource development policies will remain aimless. Although research has been conducted in the field of digital competencies and the evolution of the role of auditors in recent years, these studies have mainly focused on developed countries and different professional systems and often lack a combined theoretical and local approach. A review of the available literature shows that a comprehensive framework for modeling the professional competencies of Iranian auditors in line with the requirements of digital transformation has not been designed. The contribution of the present study to the research and theoretical synergy is to provide a native model for the digital competencies of Iranian certified auditors by utilizing scientific methods, thus completing a neglected link in the connection between digital transformation and the auditing profession. The present study answers the key question of what is the model of professional competencies of auditors based on digital transformation in the Iranian certified accountants' community and how valid is it?
Method:
This study was conducted within the framework of the pragmatism paradigm and by adopting a combined approach of induction and deductive reasoning. This study adopts an applied and developmental approach and aims to design and validate the professional competence model of auditors in the context of digital transformation. From a methodological perspective, this study is classified as non-experimental (descriptive) research and was conducted using a cross-sectional survey strategy and a mixed exploratory research design (qualitative-quantitative). The qualitative phase involved participants such as included auditing professors and managers of the Iranian Certified Public Accountants Association, which was achieved through purposive sampling and by selecting 15 people to achieve theoretical saturation. In the quantitative section, the statistical population included managers and experts of the Iranian Certified Public Accountants Association, which was estimated to be 140 people using the Cohen power analysis rule. Interviews and questionnaires were used to collect data. The interviews were analyzed using thematic analysis and Maxqda software, and the data from the questionnaire were analyzed using the partial least squares method and SmartPLS software.
Results:
In the findings section, in order to explain the professional competence model of auditors based on digital transformation in the Iranian Association of Certified Public Accountants (IACPA), a series of semi-structured and specialized interviews were conducted with the participation of university professors in the field of accounting and auditing and senior managers of the Iranian Certified Public Accountants' Society. The qualitative data obtained from these interviews were analyzed using MaxQDA software and based on the theme analysis model based on Braun and Clarke’s (2022) six-step approach. After completing the initial steps, a comprehensive report of the qualitative analysis was prepared in the sixth step, in which 12 main themes and 72 sub-themes were extracted.
Conclusion:
The results of the study showed that the ability to manage risk and internal control with digital tools, professional and technical knowledge in the digital age, and leadership and management of digital audit teams affect the ability to use technology and smart audit tools and digital transformation in audit strategies. The aforementioned components, by affecting continuous learning and updating knowledge in the era of digital transformation, and analytical skills and critical thinking based on data, lead to creativity and innovation in digital auditing. Ultimately, the professional competencies of auditors are achieved through communication and interpersonal skills in the digital environment, ethics and professional responsibility in the digital world, and decision-making and professional judgment skills based on artificial intelligence.
Keywords: Auditors' professional competencies, digital transformation, Iranian Certified Public Accountants' Society
Identifying and prioritizing risk factors of Internet Service Provider companies using FBWM (Case study: Shatel company)
Volume 18, Spring & Summer 2026, July 2026
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.91710.1673
zahra ghasemkhani, Saeed Tavakolian, payam farhadi
Abstract The main purpose of the present study is to identify, structure and prioritize risk factors of internet service provider (ISP) companies by using multi-criteria decision-making methods. This research is applied in terms of aim and descriptive-survey regarding data collection. The experts committee are included high-level managers of the Shatel company that been determined through the Snowball sampling. Firstly, the initial list of risk factors is extracted from related research and then validated and classified into five groups namely political and legal, technical, financial, security and educational by use of the Fuzzy Delphi Method (FDM). Then, the global priority of each risk is resulted through the Fuzzy Best-Worst Method (FBWM). The findings show that "lack of high reliability and security of data storage", "data theft" and "Improper investment" are the most important risk factors in Shatel company with weight coefficients of 0.101, 0.077 and 0.062, respectively, which require solutions to overcome them.
Keywords: Risk Management, Internet Service Providers (ISPs), Multi-criteria Decision-Making (MCDM), Fuzzy Best-Worst Method (FBWM), Shatel company.