Designing a model of the silent change phenomenon (Case Study: Government Organizations in Lorestan Province)
Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript, Available Online from 01 July 2026
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2026.96823.1797
Ali Shariat Nejad, Mina Hoseini, Anis Moayed
Abstract Purpose: Silent change is a process in which employees gradually change their attitudes, values, motivation, and work behavior without the organization having formally decided to change. Given the hidden nature of this phenomenon, failure to recognize and manage it in a timely manner can lead to a decline in performance, reduced productivity, and the emergence of organizational crises, especially in government organizations. However, the formation and interaction of factors affecting this phenomenon have not been studied in a coherent manner in the form of a structural model. Therefore, the main goal of the present study is to identify the root factors that underlie silent change and understand how these factors relate to and influence each other in government organizations in Lorestan province. To achieve this goal, the fuzzy interpretive structural modeling method has been used to design a model of this phenomenon.
Methodology: The present study is applied in terms of purpose and has been conducted with a mixed approach (qualitative-quantitative). In the qualitative part of the research, the factors and drivers of silent change were identified through a systematic review of the literature and interviews with experts, and in the quantitative part of the research, the internal relationships and leveling of these factors were analyzed using the Fuzzy Total Interpretive Structural Modeling (TISM) method. The statistical population of the present study was experts, consisting of senior managers of government organizations along with university professors in the field of human resource management and organizational behavior, of whom 25 were selected as sample members using a purposive sampling method and based on the theoretical saturation principle. The data collection tool in the qualitative part was an interview and in the quantitative part was a questionnaire. In this study, content analysis and coding with the software MaxQDA were used to analyze the data in the qualitative part. The fuzzy interpretive structural modeling method was used to analyze the data in the quantitative part. In this study, to examine the validity and reliability of the data collection tool in the qualitative part, the content method and theoretical validity and intra-coder and inter-coder reliability were used. Also, to examine the validity and reliability of the data collection tool in the quantitative part, content validity and test-retest reliability were used.
Findings: The findings of this research include factors affecting the formation of the silent change phenomenon and presenting its model in government organizations in Lorestan province.
Results: The results of this study include presenting a model of the phenomenon of silent employee change in four axes: formation contexts, intervening and correlated factors in the formation, dimensions and consequences of the phenomenon of silent change. The formation contexts of the phenomenon of silent change include; the occurrence of invisible inequalities and discriminatory behaviors, lack of access to growth and development opportunities in the organization, ignoring human values and dignity, and lack of organizational commitment. Also, intervening and correlated factors in the formation of the phenomenon of silent change include; the manager having a narcissistic personality type, the occurrence of the phenomenon of the humanistic effect, and eliminationism instead of interactionism in the organization. In addition, the dimensions of the formation of this phenomenon include; a decrease in job engagement and a decrease in extra-role effort, organizational alienation and psychosocial withdrawal, and defensive silence. The consequences of this phenomenon include; a decrease in the efficiency and productivity of the organization, the emergence of destructive behaviors in the organization, poverty in producing original and innovative ideas, and a decrease in the performance of organizational citizenship.
Fuzzy Cognitive Mapping Modeling of the Causes and Consequences of Emotional Blackmail in Government Organizations of Lorestan Province
Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript, Available Online from 28 October 2026
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2026.97699.1820
Mohsen Arefnezhad, Mina Hoseini, Anis Moayed
Abstract INTRODUCTION
In the modern world, the industrial lifestyle has brought significant advancements for individuals, yet in many respects, it has also led to adverse effects such as high levels of stress and psychological pressure in their professional and personal lives. An individual’s job is expected to fulfill a substantial portion of their material, psychological, and social needs. However, factors such as poor management, inadequate planning, disregard for employees’ basic needs, and a lack of respect can lead to emotional and psychological distress. This, in turn, can give rise to a phenomenon known as emotional blackmail in the workplace. Emotional blackmail is a form of severe psychological manipulation where managers use direct or indirect threats to punish employees if their demands are not met. It is a destructive behavioral pattern that tends to emerge in work environments characterized by strong emotional ties. This behavior typically follows a recurring pattern: a manager makes a demand, and if met with resistance, exerts intense emotional pressure on the employee through threats or by inducing guilt. Victims caught in this cycle often yield to the demands temporarily to alleviate the tension. However, this gradually leads to feelings of weakness, hopelessness, and an erosion of their ability to set personal boundaries.
METHODOLOGY
The present study is an exploratory research in terms of its purpose and in terms of data collection. This research is also a mixed qualitative and quantitative research based on the inductive deductive philosophy. The statistical population of the research is experts consisting of university professors in the field of human resource management, organizational behavior, and managers of government organizations in Lorestan province, who were selected using purposive sampling and based on the principle of theoretical adequacy. The data collection tool in the qualitative part is an interview, the validity and reliability of which was confirmed using content validity and theoretical validity and the method of intra-coder and extra-coder reliability. Also, the data collection tool in the quantitative part is a questionnaire, the validity and reliability of which was confirmed using content validity and test-retest reliability. The qualitative data were analyzed using content analysis and MaxQD software, and the quantitative data were analyzed using fuzzy cognitive mapping.
RESULTS & DISCUSSION
Emotional blackmail is one of the most complex and destructive forms of workplace abuse, often hidden beneath the layers of seemingly normal relationships. In emotional blackmail, an individual, such as a manager or coworker, uses emotional arousal to manipulate employees into doing things they are unwilling to do themselves, using fears and emotional vulnerabilities to manipulate employees. In fact, this tactic involves creating feelings of guilt and implicit threats such as losing their jobs or career advancement opportunities to exploit employees. This phenomenon in government organizations over time causes burnout, reduced self-confidence, and gradual deterioration of employees' mental health. Because they are constantly in a cycle of anxiety and trying to please the person who is the emotional blackmailer. Therefore, the present study was conducted with the aim of modeling a fuzzy cognitive map of the causes and consequences of emotional blackmail in government organizations in Lorestan province. The results of the study indicate that among the causes of emotional blackmail, the most important causes are the effects of blameworthy behaviors on the part of the manager, the existence of silent self-interested expectations, managers being involved in the phenomenon of deceit at work, organizational bullying, and the manager having a Machiavellian personality type. Also, among the consequences of the emotional blackmail phenomenon, the most important consequences are the occurrence of emotional resignation in employees, the emergence of a state of distrust and a toxic organizational atmosphere, the decline in job satisfaction, the spread of pessimism in the organization, and the employees' job and emotional burnout.
CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
Given that the research findings indicate the phenomenon of emotional blackmail has structural roots—such as non-transparent processes and weak oversight systems—in addition to its interpersonal dimension, the following clear and practical managerial implications are proposed. These are intended for managers in the public organizations of Lorestan province and are generalizable to other public and governmental organizations nationwide:
Clarifying Expectations and Roles: The research findings indicate that unspoken and self-serving expectations are a primary cause of emotional blackmail. Since emotional abuse and tacit expectations thrive in an environment of ambiguous roles and work boundaries, it is recommended that managers in public organizations immediately review and disseminate detailed job descriptions for all positions, complete with clear performance indicators, and provide practical solutions to eliminate any ambiguity in work expectations. Furthermore, the organization’s Code of Ethics should explicitly prohibit any personal exploitation of managerial positions, and the Ethics Committee should be tasked with monitoring and invalidating directives issued outside of the legal framework under the guise of informal relationships.
Preventing Destructive Behaviors: The findings also show that the emergence of vandalistic and destructive behaviors is another consequence of emotional blackmail in public organizations. When the voices of victimized employees are not heard, this pressure can manifest as the destruction of property or sabotage of organizational processes. Therefore, to prevent this outcome, it is essential for managers to establish a formal and secure grievance system (going beyond traditional suggestion boxes) and to conduct quarterly job satisfaction surveys. This data can serve as a management dashboard, helping senior leaders identify hotspots of crisis and silent discontent before they escalate into destructive organizational behaviors.
Combating Emotional Resignation: The research indicates that emotional blackmail leads to emotional resignation among employees (i.e., physical presence without psychological commitment). To counter this, it is proposed that managers shift their approach from purely supervisory to supportive. This requires establishing a confidential organizational psychological counseling unit or system to support employees under pressure. Additionally, emotional intelligence (EQ) and communication skills should be included as primary prerequisites in the evaluation and appointment of mid-level managers and supervisors to institutionalize a supportive approach within the management layers.
Addressing Organizational Cynicism: The findings show that the proliferation of organizational cynicism is another outcome of emotional blackmail. To counter the deep-seated cynicism resulting from this behavior, senior managers in public organizations must create secure and impartial reporting channels to build employee trust. To this end, implementing a fully confidential whistleblowing or reporting system, directly overseen by the highest executive authority (e.g., the CEO or an inspection board), is essential so that employees can report unhealthy behaviors without fear of retaliation. Moreover, using external industrial psychologists and auditors for periodic “communication health audits” will help eliminate reliance on biased internal reports.
Restoring Employee Value and Dignity: The present study reveals that inducing feelings of worthlessness and futility in employees is another consequence of emotional blackmail, stemming from the use of non-transparent and subjective appraisal systems. Therefore, it is recommended that senior managers completely redesign the performance appraisal process. This entails replacing traditional forms with a system based on objective, measurable, and transparent Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) and behavioral indicators. Furthermore, mid-level managers must be required to provide documented and constructive feedback in regular (e.g., monthly) meetings, where they not only evaluate performance but also actively listen to employee concerns. This two-way approach is a vital step in countering managerial neglect and restoring employees’ professional dignity.
Eradicating Organizational Bullying: According to the research findings, organizational bullying is a primary root cause of emotional blackmail. Verbal warnings are insufficient to correct such behaviors, requiring a systematic and structural intervention from senior management. It is therefore proposed that managers and employees in public organizations be required to sign a commitment charter on professional and ethical boundaries. To ensure its enforcement, establishing an independent Organizational Ethics Committee including elected employee representatives to guarantee impartiality is crucial. This committee will be responsible for continuously monitoring policies and decisively addressing instances of administrative bullying through transparent disciplinary processes. In parallel, all managers and staff should be required to attend periodic training workshops focused on effective communication and conflict management techniques to fundamentally shift the organizational culture towards mutual respect and professionalism.
Designing the model of the emergence of exploitative leadership using interpretive structural modeling (Case of Study: Govermental Organizations)
Volume 18, Spring & Summer 2026, July 2026
https://doi.org/10.22067/tmj.2025.92642.1690
Reza Sepahvand, Ali Shariat Nejad, Shaghayegh Salehabadi, Mina Hoseini
Abstract INTRODUCTION
Today, leadership plays an important and decisive role in the success and sustainability of organizations, as it is considered one of the most influential factors on employee behavior in the workplace. It can be said with confidence that the role of leadership is one of the most effective and important components that makes a difference in the way organizations are run, and it is clear that in the current situation, leadership styles have gained an important relationship with the success and failure of organizations. The occurrence of negative and destructive behaviors by some organizational leaders indicates that leaders do not always have appropriate behaviors and effective performance. Exploitative leaders are an example of such leaders who, with their selfish behaviors towards subordinates, always put pressure on them, which in this way prevents the growth and promotion of employees and the organization. In this way, exploitative leaders try to achieve their personal goals and interests by assigning difficult and difficult tasks and also applying double and comprehensive pressures to their employees. While there is no career advancement and development for employees. Such leadership in the workplace causes stress in employees, so that they drain the motivation and energy of employees. In fact, these leaders also cause mental, psychological, and emotional distress to subordinates with their hostile behaviors. Exploitative leaders create division among their subordinates and constantly challenge them. Due to being in a position of power, these leaders experience a kind of baseless and irrational dominance. Exploitative leaders are self-centered and do not value or respect others. Therefore, exploitative leaders are considered a serious threat to the self-esteem of subordinates in a way that prevents leaders from behaving with dignity and respect towards them. In fact, the exploitative leadership style is one of the complications and weaknesses of leadership that focuses on advancing the leader's personal interests through exploitation and neglect of the interests of subordinates.
METHODOLOGY
The present study is based on mixed qualitative and quantitative research in the inductive deductive paradigm, which is applied in terms of purpose and descriptive-survey in terms of nature and method. The statistical population of this study is experts who include university professors in the field of organizational behavior management and human resource management as well as senior managers of government organizations, whose sample members were selected by snowball sampling method and based on the principle of theoretical adequacy, 30 of them. Also, in the quantitative part, due to the information familiarity of the sample members with the research topic, the same previous sample was used. They were selected. The data collection tool in the qualitative part is a semi-structured interview, whose validity and reliability were tested by content validity and theoretical validity, and intra-coder and inter-coder reliability. Also, the data collection tool in the quantitative part is a questionnaire, whose validity and reliability were measured by content validity and test-retest reliability.
RESULTS & DISCUSSION
Considering the importance of the role of government organizations in today's society, it should be noted that if the leaders of these organizations do not have leadership qualifications and competence, they can leave dangerous effects on the organization with any of their behaviors such as; incompetent leadership, corruption, sabotage, unethical behavior, and criminal behavior. Therefore, it can be said that paying attention to the leadership style of managers, especially exploitative leadership, in these organizations is of particular importance. In fact, in government organizations in Lorestan province, the performance and actions of leaders do not always pave the way for the success and progress of the organization, and in some cases, the emergence of negative and unethical leadership styles such as; exploitative leadership can be the cause of pushing employees and the organization towards weakening performance. In general, exploitative leadership can have negative consequences and effects on employee performance and consequently on the performance of the organization. If the negative role of exploitative leadership is ignored and no effort is made to prevent or strengthen this leadership style, its consequences will ultimately affect the entire organization. The present study seeks to answer the question of what the pattern of formation of exploitative leadership is like in government organizations of Lorestan province using the interpretive structural modeling method.
CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
The basis of the results of the present study, considering its mixed nature, consists of the findings of the qualitative and quantitative sections. So that in the qualitative section of the research, the factors affecting the exploitative leadership style were identified through interviews with experts and using the coding method and the Atlas software, the desired data. Regarding the method of coding and extracting qualitative data, it should be noted that considering the nature of the questions and the way the experts responded, the exact words and phrases they mentioned were in the form of components related to exploitative leadership, that the selective, axial and open coding method was used. Then, in the quantitative section, the model of the emergence of exploitative leadership was presented. In this way, by designing a questionnaire whose rows and columns formed the factors affecting exploitative leadership in the form of a matrix, the experts were asked to respond to the questionnaire using the interpretive structural modeling method, which ultimately presented the model of the emergence of exploitative leadership. The findings of the qualitative part of the research indicate that the conditions for the formation of exploitative leadership with a narcissistic personality, Machiavellian personality type, and extreme ambition provide in government organizations of Lorestan province. Also, the results of this part indicate that the dimensions of exploitative leadership include gaining credibility, weakening employees, creating discord, creating stress and psychological distress in government organizations of Lorestan province. In addition, the findings showed that managerial colonialism and exploitation of subordinates, administrative profiteering and seeking a share of organizational resources, dominance and totalitarianism are factors in the emergence of exploitative leaders. Finally, the qualitative findings indicate that minimizing the effective exchange between members and leaders, the emergence of a paranoid atmosphere and the spread of pessimism in the organization, and the lack of production of original and innovative ideas are the consequences of exploitative leadership. Also, the results of the quantitative part indicate the exploitative leadership pattern at four levels. The research model is based on four levels of formation contexts and platforms, dimensions of exploitative leadership, emergence of exploitative leaders and its consequences. Regarding the developed model, it should be stated that in order to prevent the emergence of exploitative leadership, it is necessary to prevent the provision of the necessary contexts and platforms. These contexts include narcissistic personality, having a Machiavellian personality type, and extreme ambition. Also, the dimensions of exploitative leadership refer to gaining credibility, weakening employees, causing discord, creating stress and psychological distress. When the contexts for the formation of exploitative leadership and its dimensions are provided, the factors for the emergence of exploitative leadership, which include managerial colonialism and exploitation of subordinates, administrative profiteering and seeking a share of organizational resources, hegemony and totalitarianism, are strengthened and ultimately consequences such as; minimizing the effective exchange between members and leaders, the emergence of a paranoid atmosphere and the spread of pessimism in the organization, and the poverty of producing original and innovative ideas are directed at government organizations in Lorestan province.
Based on the findings, the present study suggests that government organizations in Lorestan province pay special attention to the style and characteristics of exploitative leaders, because the research findings show that the destructive behaviors and ineffective personal competencies of such leaders will lead to harmful consequences for organizations. Based on what has been stated, the following practical suggestions can be made to reduce the destructive effects of this leadership style:Based on the research findings, it was determined that divisiveness is one of the dimensions of exploitative leadership. Given that this characteristic can create disagreement and conflict among subordinates, so that the spirit of employee participation is destroyed by employing a confrontational and defensive strategy in the organization, and as a result, employees become unaware of the organization's main goals and ideals and become confused. First of all, it is suggested that managers learn about effective leadership styles by using scientific articles and apply them, so that the emergence of discord in the organization can be prevented as much as possible. It is also suggested that leaders and managers of government organizations strengthen and promote an organizational culture based on respect in order to reduce discord. In this way, organizational values such as mutual respect and cooperation in the organization are emphasized. Also, managers can identify the early signs of discord by using conflict management tactics in a constructive way and take action to prevent its escalation.